| Team | Years | Player | Position | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New England Patriots | 2000-Present | Tom Brady | Quarterback | 100%
|
| Miami Dolphins | 1983-1999 | Dan Marino | Quarterback | 95%
|
| Detroit Lions | 1989-1998 | Barry Sanders | Running Back | 93%
|
| Denver Broncos | 1983-1998 | John Elway | Quarterback | 90%
|
| Baltimore Ravens | 1996-2012 | Ray Lewis | Middle Linebacker | 90%
|
| New York Giants | 2004-Present | Eli Manning | Quarterback | 89%
|
| Green Bay Packers | 2005-Present | Aaron Rodgers | Quarterback | 86%
|
| Dallas Cowboys | 1989-2000 | Troy Aikman | Quarterback | 84%
|
| Pittsburgh Steelers | 2004-Present | Ben Roethlisberger | Quarterback | 79%
|
| Indianapolis Colts | 1996-2008 | Marvin Harrison | Wide Reciever | 77%
|
| Buffalo Bills | 1986-1996 | Jim Kelly | Quarterback | 73%
|
| Dallas Cowboys | 1988-1999 | Michael Irvin | Wide Reciever | 70%
|
| Pittsburgh Steelers | 2003-2014 | Troy Polamalu | Strong Safety | 69%
|
| New York Giants | 1993-2007 | Michael Strahan | Defensive End | 67%
|
| Chicago Bears | 2000-2012 | Brian Urlacher | Middle Linebacker | 65%
|
| Pittsburgh Steelers | 1998-2011 | Hines Ward | Wide Reciever | 57%
|
| Indianapolis Colts | 2001-2014 | Reggie Wayne | Wide Reciver | 56%
|
| Denver Broncos | 1995-2001 | Terrell Davis | Running Back | 54%
|
| Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 1995-2008 | Derrick Brooks | Outside Linebacker | 42%
|
| Kansas City Chiefs | 1989-1999 | Derrick Thomas | Outside Linebacker | 42%
|
| Baltimore Ravens | 1996-2007 | Jonathan Ogden | Left Tackle | 37%
|
| Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans | 1983-2001 | Bruce Matthews | Offensive Linemen | 34%
|
| Seattle Seahawks | 1997-2008 | Walter Jones | Left Tackle | 30%
|
| Washington Redskins | 1983-2002 | Darrell Green | Cornerback | 29%
|