| Rank | Answer | Years | Song | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | The Phantom of the Opera | (1988-Present) | All I Ask of You | 86%
|
| #2 | Les Misérables | (1987-2003) | One Day More | 84%
|
| #3 | Cats | (1982-2000) | Grizabella | 82%
|
| #14 | Grease | (1972-1980) | Beauty School Dropout | 79%
|
| #6 | Wicked | (2003-Present) | Thank Goodness | 68%
|
| #4 | The Lion King | (1997-Present) | The Morning Report | 54%
|
| #5 | Chicago | (1996-Present) | All I Care About | 53%
|
| #12 | Beauty and the Beast | (1994-2007) | Something There | 52%
|
| #16 | Hairspray | (2002-2009) | The Big Dollhouse | 52%
|
| #11 | Rent | (1996-2008) | I Should Tell You | 52%
|
| #7 | A Chorus Line | (1975-1990) | What I Did For Love | 48%
|
| #8 | Mamma Mia! | (2001-Present) | The Name of the Game | 43%
|
| #15 | Fiddler on the Roof | (1964-1972) | Miracle of Miracles | 40%
|
| #18 | Guys and Dolls | (1950-1953) | If I Were a Bell | 39%
|
| #13 | Annie | (1983-1997) | A New Deal for Christmas | 33%
|
| #17 | My Fair Lady | (1956-1962) | With a Little Bit of Life | 24%
|
| #9 | Jersey Boys | (2005-Present) | Big Man in Town | 17%
|
| #20 | Pippin | (1972-1977) | Morning Glow | 17%
|
| #19 | 42nd Street | (1980-1989) | Getting Out of Town | 13%
|
| #10 | Oh! Calcutta! | (1976-1989) | Suite for 5 Letters | 9%
|