| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Pirate captain of The Black Pearl | Captain Jack Sparrow | 99%
|
| Young blacksmith turned pirate | William Turner | 93%
|
| ^Daughter of the governor of Port Royal and love interest of above turned pirate | Elizabeth Swann | 89%
|
| ^Mutinous first mate of above | Hector Barbossa | 86%
|
| Captain of The Flying Dutchman | Davy Jones | 76%
|
| Commodore of the British Royal Navy at Port Royal | Commodore James Norrington | 74%
|
| Superstitious pirate and right-hand man to the captain of The Black Pearl | Joshamee Gibbs | 66%
|
| Governor of Port Royal | Governor Weatherby Swann | 64%
|
| Pirate father of young blacksmith from first film; serves on The Flying Dutchman | "Bootstrap Bill" Turner | 63%
|
| Captain of The Queen Anne's Revenge | Edward 'Blackbeard' Teach | 61%
|
| Lord of the East India Trading Company | Lord Cutler Beckett | 57%
|
| Goddess of the Sea | Calypso | 50%
|
| Pirate with no tongue and a talking parrot | Mr. Cotton | 49%
|
| Skinny, humorous pirate with a wooden eye; cursed aboard The Black Pearl | Ragetti | 49%
|
| Stout, humorous pirate; cursed aboard The Black Pearl | Pintel | 46%
|
| Pirate Captain from Singapore; one of the Nine Pirate Lords | Captain Sao Feng | 45%
|
| ^Daughter of above; love interest of the Captain of The Black Pearl | Angelica Teach | 43%
|
| Caribbean voodoo priestess; human form of the Goddess of the Sea | Tia Dalma | 42%
|
| King of Great Britain | King George II of England | 30%
|
| Midget pirate | Marty | 29%
|
| Keeper of the Pirate Code; father of the Captain of The Black Pearl | Captain Edward Teague | 26%
|
| Fiery, Caribbean pirate whose boat was stolen | Anamaria | 24%
|
| Tortuga prostitute who is always upset with the Captain of The Black Pearl | Scarlett | 21%
|
| Scarred, murderous assistant to the lord of the East India Trading Company | Ian Mercer | 20%
|
| British Naval Minuteman who likes to argue | Mullroy | 20%
|
| ^Prostitute sister of the above, who also hates the Captain of The Black Pearl | Giselle | 18%
|
| Chinese Pirate Lord | Mistress Ching | 18%
|
| Mermaid captured by the crew of The Queen Anne's Revenge | Syrena | 18%
|
| Missionary trapped aboard The Queen Anne's Revenge | Phillip Swift | 17%
|
| ^Partner to above, very dim-witted | Murtogg | 16%
|
| ^Right-hand man to above daughter | Scrum | 15%
|
| Flag Lieutenant to the Commodore of Port Royal | Lieutenant Gillette | 13%
|
| Large, African pirate; cursed aboard The Black Pearl | Bo'Sun | 11%
|
| Indian Pirate Lord | Sri Sumbhajee Angria | 11%
|
| African Pirate Lord | Gentleman Jocard | 10%
|
| Lieutenant to Commodore of Port Royal | Lieutenant Theodore Groves | 10%
|
| Psychic zombie aboard The Queen Anne's Revenge | The Quartermaster | 10%
|
| Lanky, Irish pirate; cursed aboard the The Black Pearl | Twigg | 10%
|
| British Judge meant to try an act of piracy before being tied up | Justice Smith | 9%
|
| French Pirate Lord | Capitaine Chevalle | 8%
|
| Pirate aboard The Flying Dutchman; has a hammerhead-shark appearance | Maccus | 8%
|
| Turkish Pirate Lord | Ammand the Corsair | 7%
|
| Spanish Pirate Lord | Eduardo Villaneuva | 7%
|
| Short, bearded pirate who likes to use bombs; cursed aboard The Black Pearl | Jacoby | 7%
|
| Pirate who likes to fight with grappling hooks; cursed aboard The Black Pearl | Grapple | 6%
|
| African pirate with dreadlocks; cursed aboard The Black Pearl | Koehler | 6%
|
| ^First-mate of above Pirate Lord | Tai Huang | 6%
|
| Spanish captain sent out to find the Fountain of Youth | The Spaniard | 6%
|
| Pirate aboard The Flying Dutchman; appears to be attached to the ships framework | Wyvern | 6%
|
| Pirate aboard The Flying Dutchman; has a shell for a head | Hadras | 5%
|
| Spanish King who seeks to destroy the Fountain of Youth | King Ferdinand VI of Spain | 5%
|
| Pirate who likes to use a mallot; cursed aboard The Black Pearl | Mallot | 5%
|
| Captain of the Edinburgh Trader | Captain Bellamy | 4%
|
| Brutish African zombie aboard The Queen Anne's Revenge | The Gunner | 4%
|
| Pirate aboard The Flying Dutchman; looks like corral | Palifico | 3%
|
| Indian pirate who helps the Captain of The Black Pearl in Dead Man's Chest | Leech | 2%
|
| Pirate aboard The Flying Dutchman; has four legs and a shell on his back | Penrod | 2%
|
| Pirate aboard The Flying Dutchman; hides tentacles within his body | Weedey | 1%
|