| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Oldest Brother | Dean | 100%
|
| Youngest Brother | Sam | 100%
|
| Brother's fatherly figure | Bobby | 99%
|
| Angel in a trench coat | Castiel | 99%
|
| Brother's Father | John | 99%
|
| Brother's Mother | Mary | 99%
|
| The first fallen angel | Lucifer | 94%
|
| Demon who offers her own blood to Sam | Ruby | 94%
|
| The brother's half-brother | Adam | 93%
|
| Yellow eyed demon | Azazel | 88%
|
| The sassy english demon | Crowley | 86%
|
| First demon ever made | Lilith | 84%
|
| Angel that fell from grace | Anna | 82%
|
| Creator of the Colt | Samuel Colt | 82%
|
| Female "thief" of supernatural items of value | Bela Talbot | 65%
|
| Bobby's wife | Karen | 43%
|
| First demon you meet | Meg | 43%
|