| Opening Number | Musical | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Circle of Life | The Lion King | 96%
|
| Aquarius | Hair | 94%
|
| Good Morning Baltimore | Hairspray | 89%
|
| Oh, What a Beautiful Mornin' | Oklahoma | 71%
|
| Wilkomen | Cabaret | 60%
|
| Tradition | Fiddler on the Roof | 58%
|
| Look Down | Les Miserables | 58%
|
| Oh, The Thinks You Can Think! | Seussical the Musical | 54%
|
| Good News | Wicked | 41%
|
| Why Can't the English? | My Fair Lady | 40%
|
| It Sucks to be Me | Avenue Q | 39%
|
| Summertime | Porgy and Bess | 33%
|
| I, Don Quixote | Man of LaMancha | 32%
|
| Magic to Do | Pippin | 32%
|
| Opening Night | The Producers | 30%
|
| Fugue for Tin Horns | Guys and Dolls | 27%
|
| Alma Mater | Grease | 23%
|
| Comedy Tonight | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | 22%
|
| Another Op'nin, Another Show | Kiss Me Kate | 21%
|
| Tower of Babble | Godspell | 16%
|
| A Woman Who Arranges Things | Hello Dolly | 16%
|
| I Wonder What the King is Doing Tonight | Camelot | 14%
|
| Night Waltz | A Little Night Music | 13%
|
| An English Teacher | Bye Bye Birdie | 13%
|
| The Audition | 42nd Street | 8%
|
| Everybody's Got the Right | Assassins | 8%
|
| Fancy Dress | The Drowsy Chaperone | 6%
|
| The Happiest Town in Town | Young Frankenstein | 5%
|
| Instructions for the Audience | The Frogs | 3%
|