| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Angel who's best friends with the Winchesters | Castiel | 98%
|
| Father of the brothers | John | 98%
|
| Brother's friend and father figure | Bobby | 97%
|
| Oldest Brother | Dean Winchester | 96%
|
| Youngest Brother | Sam Winchester | 96%
|
| Angel who posed as Trickster | Gabriel | 92%
|
| Prophet who wrote books about the brothers | Chuck | 87%
|
| First fallen angel | Lucifer | 87%
|
| Demon who helped the youngest brother start the apocalypse | Ruby | 84%
|
| Oldest Demon | Lilith | 76%
|
| Oldest brother's friend who's a vampire | Benny | 73%
|
| Mother of all monsters | Eve | 69%
|
| Prophet in Season 7 & 8 | Kevin Tran | 65%
|
| Angel who saved Cas from Purgatory | Naomi | 44%
|
| Stole priceless supernatural items | Bela Talbot | 35%
|