| Category | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Home Runs | Ken Griffey Jr. | 94%
|
| Hits | Ichiro Suzuki | 91%
|
| Shutouts | Randy Johnson | 88%
|
| Doubles | Edgar Martinez | 87%
|
| WAR (Pitcher) | Felix Hernandez | 84%
|
| Wins | Jamie Moyer | 70%
|
| Strikeouts (Batter) | Jay Buhner | 63%
|
| Slugging Percentage (min. 1000 PA) | Alex Rodriguez | 62%
|
| #10 in WAR | Alvin Davis | 40%
|
| #13 in WAR | Bret Boone | 38%
|
| Saves | Kazuhiro Sasaki | 35%
|
| Strikeouts (Batter, single season) | Mike Cameron | 30%
|
| Caught Stealing | Harold Reynolds | 29%
|
| Defensive WAR | Dan Wilson | 27%
|
| #12 in WAR | Freddy Garcia | 26%
|
| #11 in WAR | Mark Langston | 24%
|
| Losses | Mike Moore | 23%
|
| #9 in WAR (Batters/Pitchers) | Adrian Beltre | 22%
|
| #16 in WAR | John Olerud | 22%
|
| Least Walks Per 9 IP (Pitcher) | Hisashi Iwakuma | 19%
|
| Games Finished | J.J. Putz | 15%
|
| Games (Pitched) | Jeff Nelson | 13%
|
| #19 in WAR | Raul Ibanez | 12%
|
| Intentional Walks (Allowed) | Michael Jackson | 11%
|
| Least HR Per 9 IP (Pitcher) | Bill Swift | 6%
|
| #17 in WAR | Erik Hanson | 5%
|
| Win-Loss Percentage (min. 50 starts) | Paul Abbott | 3%
|
| ERA (min. 250 IP) | Tom Wilhelmsen | 3%
|
| #20 in WAR | Jim Beattie | 2%
|
| Stolen Base % | Henry Cotto | 1%
|
| Slugging Percentage (min. 100 PA) | Mark Whiten | 1%
|
| ERA+ (min. 150 IP) | Rafael Soriano | 1%
|