| Nickname | Competitor | Faction (If any) | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Miss Movies | Brianne Chandler | The Missfits (Formerly) | 100%
|
| The Stuckmannizer | Chris Stuckmann | N/A | 100%
|
| Classy | Clarke Wolfe | The Fyffe Club (Formerly) | 100%
|
| The Godfather | Drew McWeeny | The Usual Suspects/The Family (Formerly) | 100%
|
| The Nightmare | Hector Navarro | The Young Bucks (Formerly) | 100%
|
| Justice | Jason Inman | The Five Horsemen (Formerly) | 100%
|
| The Insneider | Jeff Sneider | Roxstars/The Lion's Den (Formerly) | 100%
|
| The Joker | Jeremy Jahns | N/A | 100%
|
| The Android | Marc Andreyko | Roxstars/The Fyffe Club (Formerly)/The Lion's Den (Formerly) | 100%
|
| The Killer/K.O. | Mike Kalinowski | KOrruption/The League (Formerly) | 100%
|
| N/A (Former team - Wangers) | RB3 | S.W.A.G./The Young Bucks (Formerly) | 100%
|
| The Captain | Robert Meyer Burnett | The Burning Droogs/The Family (Formerly)/The Lion's Den (Formerly)/The Four Horsemen (Formerly) | 100%
|
| The Inglorious One | Samm Levine | The Usual Suspects | 100%
|
| Sassy | Stacy Howard | Roxstars/KOrruption (Formerly)/The Viper Squad (Formerly) | 100%
|
| The Beast | William Bibbiani | The Quirky Mercs/The Growling Commandos (Formerly)/The Four Horsemen (Formerly) | 100%
|
| The Haymaker | Adam Hlavac | S.W.A.G. | 75%
|
| Only player to be banned | Andy Signore | N/A | 75%
|
| The Robin | Ashley V. Robinson | N/A | 75%
|
| N/A (Former Team - Double Jeopardy) | Brad Rutter | N/A | 75%
|
| The Olympian | Cody Miller | N/A | 75%
|
| The Master | Freddie Prinze Jr. | N/A | 75%
|
| N/A (Former Team - The Reel Rejects) | Greg Alba | The Quirky Mercs/The Young Bucks (Formerly) | 75%
|
| The Mad Hatter | John Humphrey | The Quirky Mercs/The Young Bucks (Formerly) | 75%
|
| The Vulture | Jonathan Voytko | N/A | 75%
|
| The Wardog | Kara Warner | N/A | 75%
|
| The Sergeant | Khail Anonymous | N/A | 75%
|
| Scary | Perri Nemiroff | N/A | 75%
|
| The Warrior | Sam Witwer | The Fyffe Club (Formerly) | 75%
|
| El Mayimbe | Umberto Gonzalez | N/A | 75%
|