| Album | Weeks On | Peak | Artist(s) | Song | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Piano Man | 14 Weeks | #25 | Billy Joel | Piano Man | 97%
|
| An Innocent Man | 22 Weeks | #3 | Billy Joel | Uptown Girl | 90%
|
| Storm Front | 19 Weeks | #1 (2 Weeks) | Billy Joel | We Didn't Start the Fire | 85%
|
| River of Dreams | 27 Weeks | #3 | Billy Joel | The River of Dreams | 77%
|
| An Innocent Man | 18 Weeks | #10 | Billy Joel | An Innocent Man | 71%
|
| The Stranger | 27 Weeks | #3 | Billy Joel | Just the Way You Are | 64%
|
| The Stranger | 15 Weeks | #17 | Billy Joel | She's Always a Woman | 64%
|
| Glass Houses | 21 Weeks | #1 (2 Weeks) | Billy Joel | It's Still Rock and Roll To Me | 63%
|
| The Nylon Curtain | 22 Weeks | #17 | Billy Joel | Allentown | 60%
|
| Glass Houses | 15 Weeks | #7 | Billy Joel | You May Be Right | 60%
|
| The Stranger | 13 Weeks | #24 | Billy Joel | Only the Good Die Young | 58%
|
| 52nd Street | 19 Weeks | #3 | Billy Joel | My Life | 56%
|
| An Innocent Man | 18 Weeks | #1 (1 Week) | Billy Joel | Tell Her About It | 53%
|
| An Innocent Man | 18 Weeks | #14 | Billy Joel | The Longest Time | 53%
|
| 52nd Street | 11 Weeks | #14 | Billy Joel | Big Shot | 52%
|
| The Nylon Curtain | 7 Weeks | #56 | Billy Joel | Goodnight Saigon | 45%
|
| Streetlife Serenade | 10 Weeks | #34 | Billy Joel | The Entertainer | 44%
|
| The Nylon Curtain | 17 Weeks | #20 | Billy Joel | Pressure | 42%
|
| The Bridge | 7 Weeks | #75 | Billy Joel ft. Ray Charles | Baby Grand | 38%
|
| 52nd Street | 11 Weeks | #24 | Billy Joel | Honesty | 38%
|
| Storm Front | 8 Weeks | #57 | Billy Joel | The Downeaster 'Alexa' | 38%
|
| The Bridge | 18 Weeks | #10 | Billy Joel | A Matter of Trust | 34%
|
| Storm Front | 12 Weeks | #37 | Billy Joel | And So It Goes | 34%
|
| Glass Houses | 15 Weeks | #19 | Billy Joel | Don't Ask Me Why | 34%
|
| Songs in the Attic | 14 Weeks | #23 | Billy Joel | She's Got a Way | 32%
|
| Storm Front | 16 Weeks | #6 | Billy Joel | I Go To Extremes | 29%
|
| An Innocent Man | 16 Weeks | #18 | Billy Joel | Keeping the Faith | 29%
|
| The Stranger | 14 Weeks | #17 | Billy Joel | Movin' Out (Anthony's Song) | 29%
|
| The Bridge | 15 Weeks | #10 | Billy Joel | Modern Woman | 22%
|
| River of Dreams | 20 Weeks | #29 | Billy Joel | All About Soul | 21%
|
| An Innocent Man | 15 Weeks | #27 | Billy Joel | Leave a Tender Moment Alone | 21%
|
| Songs in the Attic | 15 Weeks | #17 | Billy Joel | Say Goodbye to Hollywood | 21%
|
| Greatest Hits – Volume I & Volume II | 10 Weeks | #34 | Billy Joel | The Night Is Still Young | 19%
|
| The Bridge | 17 Weeks | #18 | Billy Joel | This Is The Time | 18%
|
| Glass Houses | 9 Weeks | #36 | Billy Joel | Sometimes a Fantasy | 15%
|
| Storm Front | 6 Weeks | #77 | Billy Joel | That's Not Her Style | 15%
|
| Greatest Hits – Volume I & Volume II | 16 Weeks | #9 | Billy Joel | You're Only Human (Second Wind) | 14%
|
| Piano Man | 4 Weeks | #77 | Billy Joel | Travelin' Prayer | 12%
|
| Piano Man | 4 Weeks | #80 | Billy Joel | Worse Comes To Worst | 12%
|
| Honeymoon in Vegas | 3 Weeks | #92 | Billy Joel | All Shook Up | 11%
|
| Greatest Hits Volume III | 9 Weeks | #50 | Billy Joel | To Make You Feel My Love | 8%
|
| Non-Album Single | 1 Week | #62 | Billy Joel | Turn the Lights Back On | 7%
|
| River of Dreams | 8 Weeks | #77 | Billy Joel | Lullaby (Goodnight, My Angel) | 5%
|