| Hint | Answer | % Correct | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 02/03 | Arsenal | Thierry Henry | 92%
|
| 03/04 | Arsenal | Thierry Henry | 92%
|
| 09/10 | Manchester United | Wayne Rooney | 90%
|
| 06/07 | Manchester United | Cristiano Ronaldo | 88%
|
| 07/08 | Manchester United | Cristiano Ronaldo | 88%
|
| 05/06 | Liverpool | Steven Gerrard | 88%
|
| 15/16 | Leicester City | Riyad Mahrez | 87%
|
| 94/95 | Blackburn Rovers | Alan Shearer | 85%
|
| 96/97 | Newcastle United | Alan Shearer | 85%
|
| 13/14 | Liverpool | Luis Suarez | 83%
|
| 14/15 | Chelsea | Eden Hazard | 81%
|
| 08/09 | Manchester United | Ryan Giggs | 77%
|
| 11/12 | Arsenal | Robin Van Persie | 76%
|
| 10/11 | Tottenham Hotspur | Gareth Bale | 75%
|
| 12/13 | Tottenham Hotspur | Gareth Bale | 75%
|
| 93/94 | Manchester United | Eric Cantona | 64%
|
| 04/05 | Chelsea | John Terry | 63%
|
| 97/98 | Arsenal | Dennis Bergkamp | 55%
|
| 95/96 | Newcastle United | Les Ferdinand | 53%
|
| 99/00 | Manchester United | Roy Keane | 53%
|
| 01/02 | Manchester United | Ruud Van Nistelrooy | 52%
|
| 83/84 | Liverpool | Ian Rush | 50%
|
| 00/01 | Manchester United | Teddy Sheringham | 43%
|
| 82/83 | Liverpool | Kenny Dalglish | 40%
|
| 85/86 | Everton | Gary Lineker | 33%
|
| 98/99 | Tottenham Hotspur | David Ginola | 30%
|
| 88/89 | Manchester United | Mark Hughes | 30%
|
| 90/91 | Manchester United | Mark Hughes | 30%
|
| 87/88 | Liverpool | John Barnes | 28%
|
| 81/82 | Southampton | Kevin Keegan | 25%
|
| 76/77 | Aston Villa | Andy Gray | 14%
|
| 91/92 | Manchester United | Gary Pallister | 14%
|
| 92/93 | Aston Villa | Paul McGrath | 13%
|
| 80/81 | Ipswich Town | John Wark | 12%
|
| 86/87 | Tottenham Hotspur | Clive Allen | 11%
|
| 84/85 | Everton | Peter Reid | 11%
|
| 77/78 | Nottingham Forest | Peter Shilton | 11%
|
| 78/79 | Arsenal | Liam Brady | 10%
|
| 89/90 | Aston Villa | David Platt | 9%
|
| 73/74 | Leeds United | Norman Hunter | 8%
|
| 79/80 | LiverpooI | Terry McDermott | 8%
|
| 74/75 | Derby County | Colin Todd | 6%
|
| 75/76 | Tottenham Hotspur | Pat Jennings | 5%
|