| Album | Artist | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The Eminem Show | The Marshall Mathers LP | Eminem | 100%
|
| American Idiot | Green Day | 89%
|
| A Rush of Blood to the Head | Parachutes | Viva la Vida | X&Y | Coldplay | 84%
|
| Demon Days | Gorillaz | Gorillaz | 84%
|
| The Black Album | The Blueprint | The Blueprint 3 | Jay-Z | 79%
|
| Graduation | Late Registration | The College Dropout | Kanye West | 79%
|
| FutureSex/LoveSounds | Justin Timberlake | 74%
|
| Pearl Jam | Pearl Jam | 74%
|
| Get Rich or Die Tryin' | 50 Cent | 68%
|
| Back to Black | Amy Winehouse | 68%
|
| Speakerboxxx/The Love Below | Stankonia | OutKast | 68%
|
| Aaliyah | Aaliyah | 58%
|
| Franz Ferdinand | Franz Ferdinand | 58%
|
| Hybrid Theory | Meteora | Linkin Park | 58%
|
| Miss E... So Addictive | Under Construction | Missy Elliot | 58%
|
| Confessions | Usher | 58%
|
| The Fame | Lady Gaga | 53%
|
| Tha Carter III | Lil Wayne | 53%
|
| The Emancipation of Mimi | Mariah Carey | 53%
|
| Music | Madonna | 47%
|
| Amnesiac | Hail to the Thief | In Rainbows | Kid A | Radiohead | 47%
|
| By the Way | Stadium Arcadium | Red Hot Chili Peppers | 47%
|
| Mezmerize | Toxicity | System of a Down | 47%
|
| The E.N.D. | The Black Eyed Peas | 47%
|
| Elephant | Get Behind Me Satan | Icky Thump | White Blood Cells | The White Stripes | 47%
|
| All That You Can't Leave Behind | How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb | U2 | 47%
|
| Vampire Weekend | Vampire Weekend | 42%
|
| Whatever People Say I Am That's What I Am Not | Arctic Monkeys | 37%
|
| Missundaztood | Pink | 37%
|
| Songs in A Minor | The Diary of... | Alicia Keys | 32%
|
| Funeral | Neon Bible | Arcade Fire | 32%
|
| Black Holes and Relevations | Muse | 32%
|
| Come Away with Me | Feels Like Home | Norah Jones | 32%
|
| Hot Fuss | The Killers | 32%
|
| Is This It | The Strokes | 32%
|
| Songs for the Deaf | Queens of the Stone Age | 26%
|
| Lateralus | Tool | 26%
|
| Green Album | Weezer | 26%
|
| Only by the Night | Kings of Leon | 21%
|
| Stillmatic | Nas | 21%
|
| Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix | Phoenix | 21%
|
| Guero | Sea Change | Beck | 16%
|
| Relationship of Command | At the Drive In | 11%
|
| Vespertine | Björk | 11%
|
| St. Elsewhere | Gnarls Barkley | 11%
|
| No More Drama | The Breakthrough | Mary J. Blige | 11%
|
| Good News for People Who Love Bad News | The Moon and Antarctica | Modest Mouse | 11%
|
| Illinois | Sufjan Stevens | 11%
|
| The Rubber Factory | The Black Keys | 11%
|
| Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots | The Flaming Lips | 11%
|
| De-Loused in the Comatorium | The Mars Volta | 11%
|
| A Ghost Is Born | Yankee Hotel Foxtrot | Wilco | 11%
|
| Merriweather Post Pavilion | Animal Collective | 5%
|
| Be | Like Water for Chocolate | Common | 5%
|
| Voodoo | D'Angelo | 5%
|
| Turn on the Bright Lights | Interpol | 5%
|
| Food & Liquor | Lupe Fiasco | 5%
|
| Arlur | M.I.A. | 5%
|
| Broken Boy Soldiers | The Raconteurs | 5%
|
| Game Theory | Phrenology | The Roots | 5%
|
| Love and Theft | Modern Times | Bob Dylan | 0%
|
| SMiLE | Brian Wilson | 0%
|
| The Rising | Bruce Springsteen | 0%
|
| Busted Stuff | Dave Matthews Band | 0%
|
| Lungs | Florence + The Machine | 0%
|
| Our Endless Numbered Days | Iron & Wine | 0%
|
| Quality Control | Jurassic 5 | 0%
|
| Heartbreaker | Ryan Adams | 0%
|
| Wincing the Night Away | The Shins | 0%
|