| Year | Winner | Works | Publisher(s) | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1988 | Alan Moore | Watchmen | DC | 100%
|
| 1989 | Alan Moore | Batman: The Killing Joke | DC | 100%
|
| 1995 | Alan Moore | From Hell | Kitchen Sink | 100%
|
| 1996 | Alan Moore | From Hell | Kitchen Sink | 100%
|
| 1997 | Alan Moore | From Hell; Supreme | Kitchen Sink; Maximum Press | 100%
|
| 2000 | Alan Moore | The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen; Promethea; Tom Strong; Tomorrow Stories; Top 10 | ABC | 100%
|
| 2001 | Alan Moore | The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen; Promethea; Tom Strong; Tomorrow Stories; Top 10 | ABC | 100%
|
| 2004 | Alan Moore | The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen; Promethea; Smax; Tom Strong; Tom Strong's Terrific Tales | ABC | 100%
|
| 2006 | Alan Moore | Promethea; Top 10: The Forty-Niners | ABC | 100%
|
| 1991 | Neil Gaiman | Sandman | DC | 80%
|
| 1992 | Neil Gaiman | Sandman; The Books of Magic; Miracleman | DC; DC; Eclipse | 80%
|
| 1993 | Neil Gaiman | Sandman; Miracleman | DC; Eclipse | 80%
|
| 1994 | Neil Gaiman | Sandman | DC | 80%
|
| 2005 | Brian K. Vaughan | Y: The Last Man; Ex Machina; Runaways; Ultimate X-Men | Vertigo/DC; WildStorm/DC; Marvel; Marvel | 60%
|
| 2013 | Brian K. Vaughan | Saga | Image | 60%
|
| 2014 | Brian K. Vaughan | Saga | Image | 60%
|
| 2017 | Brian K. Vaughan | Paper Girls; Saga; We Stand On Guard | Image | 60%
|
| 1999 | Kurt Busiek | ____ ______'s Astro City; Avengers | Homage/WildStorm/Image; Marvel | 60%
|
| 2018 (tie) | Marjorie Liu | Monstress | Image | 60%
|
| 2018 (tie) | Tom King | Batman; Batman Annual #2; Batman/Elmer Fudd Special #1; Mister Miracle | DC; DC; DC; DC | 60%
|
| 2019 | Tom King | Batman, Mister Miracle, Heroes in Crisis, Swamp Thing Winter Special | DC; DC; DC; DC | 60%
|
| 2002 | Brian Michael Bendis | Powers; Alias; Daredevil; Ultimate Spider-Man | Image; Marvel; Marvel; Marvel | 40%
|
| 2003 | Brian Michael Bendis | Powers; Alias; Daredevil; Ultimate Spider-Man | Image; Marvel; Marvel; Marvel | 40%
|
| 2007 | Ed Brubaker | Captain America; Criminal; Daredevil | Marvel; Marvel; Marvel | 40%
|
| 2008 | Ed Brubaker | Captain America; Criminal; Daredevil; Immortal Iron Fist | Marvel; Marvel; Marvel; Marvel | 40%
|
| 2010 | Ed Brubaker | Captain America; Daredevil; The Marvel Project; Criminal; Incognito | Marvel; Marvel; Marvel; Marvel; Marvel | 40%
|
| 1998 | Garth Ennis | Hitman; Preacher; The Unknown Soldier; Bloody Mary: Lady Liberty | DC; DC/Vertigo; DC/Helix | 40%
|
| 2021 | James Tynion IV | Something is Killing the Children; Wynd; Batman; The Department of Truth; Razorblades | Boom!; Boom!; DC; Image; Tiny Onion | 40%
|
| 2022 | James Tynion IV | House of Slaughter; Something is Killing the Children; Wynd; The Nice House on the Lake; The Joker; Batman; DC Pride 2021; The Department of Truth; Blue Book; Razorblades | Boom!; Boom!; Boom!; DC; DC; DC; DC; Image; Tiny Onion; Tiny Onion | 40%
|
| 2023 | James Tynion IV | House of Slaughter; Something Is Killing the Children; Wynd; The Nice House on the Lake; The Sandman Universe: Nightmare Country; The Closet;The Department of Truth | Boom!; Boom!; Boom!; DC; DC; DC; Image; Image | 40%
|
| 2016 | Jason Aaron | Doctor Strange; Men of Wrath; Thor; Star Wars; Southern Bastards | Marvel; Marvel; Marvel; Marvel; Image | 40%
|
| 2012 | Mark Waid | Irredeemable; Incorruptible; Daredevil | Boom!; Boom!; Marvel | 40%
|
| 2011 | Joe Hill | Locke & Key | IDW | 20%
|
| 2020 | Mariko Tamaki | Harley Quinn: Breaking Glass; Laura Dean Keeps Breaking Up With Me | DC; First Second/Macmillan | 20%
|
| 2009 | Bill Willingham | Fables; House of Mystery | Vertigo/DC; Vertigo/DC | 0%
|
| 2015 | Gene Luen Yang | Avatar: The Last Airbender; The Shadow Hero | Dark Horse; First Second | 0%
|