Classic city proper vs urban area issue we always get on Jetpunk. When a quiz says in the caveats "urban area" the numbers will always be huge bcz of the way "city" limits are stretched to include ALL urban buildup around the core city. Check the wikipedia pages on the US's CSA and MSA city limits and populations and you'll see for yourself that these are official numbers.
Points to note about using the urban area: Of the big two Tokyo metro area is actually only around 14 million and the wider area used here covers the same area as the whole of Maryland; none of the sub cities would make the list on their own; Guangzhou/Shenzhen is also clearly on the list with about 23M in their metro areas but also has the sub-cities of Foshan and Dongguan at around 7M each.
Suzhou would also make the list at about 11M but makes sense to be included with Shanghai as a large number commute in both directions and they are going to open a metro line to connect them fairly soon.
No other agglomeration on the list has a satellite/sub-city which would make the list in its own right. However of the others: Johannesburg seems to be less than half the city itself (with 6M in East Rand West Rand and Pretoria); Singapore and Detroit both include areas in other countries; and Shantou, Dubai, Guadalajara, Wenzhou and Taipei would not make the list excluding satellite cities.
As far as I know, the area around the Pearl River delta is to be combined into a single megacity. And this is what I found on the web.
*Called the “Turn The Pearl River Delta Into One” scheme, the plan will effectively merge Guangzhou, Shenzhen, Dongguan, Foshan, Huizhou, Zhaoqing, Jiangmen, Zhongshan, and Zhuhai into a single megacity with a geographical size larger than Switzerland. *
Whereas, some cities like Guangzhou and Shenzhen are already combined.
I'm guessing one is the loosely defined "Ruhr Area," greyed out because there's no single urban center, and the other is probably Bielefeld, greyed out because it doesn't really exist.
Is there a particular reason the California Bay Area area is labelled as San Francisco rather than San Jose? I know SF is the more famous city of the two, but SJ is the larger of the two by about 100K.
I know this has already been brought up, but if you are going to accept Philly for Philadelphia and SF for San Francisco you have to accept LA for Los Angeles. I live in California, everyone calls Los Angeles LA and I rarely hear anyone refer to San Francisco as SF, usually Frisco, San Fran or the Bay.
The difference is no other cities start with 'SF' or 'Philly,' whereas there's many cities (even one on this list) that start with 'La.' That's probably why it's not an accepted type-in.
Your mind always goes directly to the ones you know are difficult to remember. Then you don't get 100%, and you look at the results and every time an obvious one pops into your head, you feel dumber, and dumber.. and dumber........ and dumber......................... and ddduuuuuummmmbbbeeerrrr..........................................................................................................................
My grandpa lived some of his teens in Pune (then spelt Poona I think) and would talk about it like it was a small town. Little did I know it was among the post populated cities in the world. I asked him about it after taking this quiz and he told me "I meant in comparison to Bombay".
No, they're not almost 2 hours apart -- they're only an hour apart via car or train. Also, they are part of the same "combined statistical area" or CSA. CSAs represent multiple metropolitan or micropolitan statistical areas that have an employment interchange of at least 15% (% commuting from A to B plus % commuting from B to A). CSAs often represent regions with overlapping labor and media markets.
80/100. I got every city outside of India and China and all but 2 in India. Very proud of this effort, and probably not going to try to memorize the cities in China LOL
people in china are crowded up more near the coast and in the cities near the coast, because of work opportunities, in factories and what not. that doesnt exist in india as people are spread out everywhere along the country
Should accept more misspellings. I had both Ho Chi Minh city and Shenzhen, but apparently could'nt spell them correctly. S/Z/C should be interchangable in a lot of cases, in my opinion. Also H's optional in some cases.
missed: 4 in North America, 2 in West Africa, 1 in Indonesia and the rest in China
How funny!
Suzhou would also make the list at about 11M but makes sense to be included with Shanghai as a large number commute in both directions and they are going to open a metro line to connect them fairly soon.
No other agglomeration on the list has a satellite/sub-city which would make the list in its own right. However of the others: Johannesburg seems to be less than half the city itself (with 6M in East Rand West Rand and Pretoria); Singapore and Detroit both include areas in other countries; and Shantou, Dubai, Guadalajara, Wenzhou and Taipei would not make the list excluding satellite cities.
As far as I know, the area around the Pearl River delta is to be combined into a single megacity. And this is what I found on the web.
*Called the “Turn The Pearl River Delta Into One” scheme, the plan will effectively merge Guangzhou, Shenzhen, Dongguan, Foshan, Huizhou, Zhaoqing, Jiangmen, Zhongshan, and Zhuhai into a single megacity with a geographical size larger than Switzerland. *
Whereas, some cities like Guangzhou and Shenzhen are already combined.
it's a second try because first try i forgot changsha zhengzhou and philadelphia, i freaking forgot philadelphia.
I missed NYC.
26 cities in China, Including the most and 3rd most populated
Yet India has a higher population in a much smaller land area.
Something definitely doesn't add up