| Character | Reason | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Ted | Stella | 68%
|
| Stuart | Drinking | 65%
|
| Everyone | Intervention | 65%
|
| Barney | Magic Tricks | 64%
|
| Marshall | The Hat | 61%
|
| Lily | British Accent | 58%
|
| Barney | Moving in with Quinn | 43%
|
| Robin | Spray Tans | 40%
|
| Robin | Barney | 26%
|
| Marshall | Charts | 24%
|
| Barney | Old Man Suit | 18%
|
| Barney | Meet his father again | 16%
|
| Ted | Zoey | 12%
|
| Ted | Pronunciation | 11%
|