| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Sue's Down-Syndrome Assistant | Becky | 95%
|
| Irish Guy | Rory | 92%
|
| She faked pregnancy | Terri | 92%
|
| Member of the Wrestling Team, Puck's ex-GF | Lauren | 90%
|
| He was the Principal, but later became the Janitor | Figgins | 89%
|
| The Substitute | Holly | 87%
|
| Rachel's Love Interest in New York | Brody | 86%
|
| Football Coach in Season One | Ken | 86%
|
| Dentist ; Emma's ex-husband | Carl | 82%
|
| Rachel's strict dance teacher | Cassandra | 81%
|
| Girl with Self-Diagnosed Asperger's Syndrome | Sugar | 81%
|
| Santana's Love Interest in New York | Dani | 74%
|
| He plays the piano in the choir room | Brad | 73%
|
| Swimming Coach | Roz | 68%
|
| Gossip Guy ; had a crush on Rachel | Jacob | 66%
|
| Tarantula Head | Joe | 65%
|
| School employee who was fired, thanks to Rachel | Sandy | 54%
|
| Blaine's brother | Cooper | 52%
|
| Mercedes' New Love Interest in Season 3 | Shane | 37%
|
| Marley's mom; works at the cafeteria | Millie | 27%
|
| NYADA Aspirant ; "Anything Goes/Anything You Can Do" | Harmony | 23%
|
| Emma's Niece | Betty | 19%
|
| Santana's Mother | Maribel | 16%
|