| Percentage | Winner | Opponent | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 98% | Ronald Reagan | Walter Mondale | 100%
|
| 90% | Ronald Reagan | Jimmy Carter | 100%
|
| 98% | Franklin D. Roosevelt | Alf Landon | 95%
|
| 88% | Franklin D. Roosevelt | Herbert Hoover | 95%
|
| 84% | Franklin D. Roosevelt | Wendell Willkie | 95%
|
| 81% | Franklin D. Roosevelt | Thomas Dewey | 95%
|
| 96% | Richard Nixon | George McGovern | 92%
|
| 90% | Lyndon B. Johnson | Barry Goldwater | 90%
|
| 86% | Dwight Eisenhower | Adlai Stevenson | 88%
|
| 83% | Dwight Eisenhower | Adlai Stevenson | 88%
|
| 83% | Woodrow Wilson | Theodore Roosevelt | 88%
|
| 90% | Abraham Lincoln | George McClellan | 83%
|
| 92% | Thomas Jefferson | Charles Pinckney | 69%
|
| 83% | James Monroe | Ruflus King | 61%
|
| 85% | Franklin Pierce | Winfield Scott | 53%
|