| Conference/Year | #1 Seed | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| AFC 2007-08 | New England Patriots | 83%
|
| AFC 2014-15 | New England Patriots | 83%
|
| AFC 2003-04 | New England Patriots | 79%
|
| AFC 2011-12 | New England Patriots | 75%
|
| NFC 2014-15 | Seattle Seahawks | 75%
|
| AFC 2012-13 | Denver Broncos | 71%
|
| AFC 2013-14 | Denver Broncos | 71%
|
| AFC 2010-11 | New England Patriots | 71%
|
| AFC 2004-05 | Pittsburgh Steelers | 71%
|
| NFC 2013-14 | Seattle Seahawks | 71%
|
| NFC 1999-00 | St. Louis Rams | 71%
|
| AFC 2009-10 | Indianapolis Colts | 67%
|
| NFC 2002-03 | Philadelphia Eagles | 67%
|
| NFC 2003-04 | Philadelphia Eagles | 63%
|
| AFC 2001-02 | Pittsburgh Steelers | 63%
|
| AFC 2005-06 | Denver Broncos | 58%
|
| NFC 2011-12 | Green Bay Packers | 58%
|
| NFC 2000-01 | New York Giants | 58%
|
| AFC 2002-03 | Oakland Raiders | 58%
|
| NFC 2004-05 | Philadelphia Eagles | 58%
|
| NFC 2007-08 | Dallas Cowboys | 54%
|
| NFC 2009-10 | New Orleans Saints | 54%
|
| NFC 2001-02 | St. Louis Rams | 54%
|
| NFC 2012-13 | Atlanta Falcons | 50%
|
| NFC 2006-07 | Chicago Bears | 50%
|
| AFC 1999-00 | Jacksonville Jaguars | 50%
|
| NFC 2008-09 | New York Giants | 50%
|
| AFC 2000-01 | Tennessee Titans | 50%
|
| NFC 2010-11 | Atlanta Falcons | 46%
|
| AFC 2006-07 | San Diego Chargers | 46%
|
| NFC 2005-06 | Seattle Seahawks | 46%
|
| AFC 2008-09 | Tennessee Titans | 46%
|