| Rank | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cuba | 97%
|
| 3 | Jamaica | 96%
|
| 5 | Trinidad | 93%
|
| 41 | Saint Kitts | 92%
|
| 35 | Antigua | 91%
|
| 29 | Saint Vincent | 90%
|
| 26 | Barbados | 87%
|
| 2 | Hispaniola | 85%
|
| 16 | Dominica | 84%
|
| 31 | Grenada | 82%
|
| 32 | Tobago | 79%
|
| 43 | Barbuda | 71%
|
| 19 | Saint Lucia | 71%
|
| 39 | Aruba | 70%
|
| 4 | Puerto Rico | 68%
|
| 58 | Nevis | 61%
|
| 25 | Curaçao | 59%
|
| 12 | Martinique | 56%
|
| 14 | Guadeloupe | 55%
|
| 10 | Grand Bahama Island | 33%
|
| 13 | Isla Margarita, Cuba | 18%
|
| 6 | North Andros Island, Bahamas | 15%
|
| 9 | South Andros Island, Bahamas | 14%
|
| 18 | Cozumel, Mexico | 13%
|
| 7 | Isla de la Juventud, Cuba | 12%
|
| 20 | Grande-Terre, Guadeloupe | 8%
|
| 8 | Great Inagua Island, Bahamas | 8%
|
| 15 | Cayo Romano, Cuba | 7%
|
| 11 | Great Abaco Island, Bahamas | 7%
|
| 17 | Gonâve, Haiti | 3%
|