| Player | Year | College | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jameis Winston | 2015 | Florida State | 95%
|
| Cam Newton | 2011 | Auburn | 94%
|
| Jared Goff | 2016 | California | 92%
|
| Andrew Luck | 2012 | Stanford | 90%
|
| Matthew Stafford | 2009 | Georgia | 87%
|
| Jadeveon Clowney | 2014 | South Carolina | 87%
|
| Myles Garrett | 2017 | Texas A&M | 87%
|
| Eli Manning | 2004 | Ole Miss | 84%
|
| Peyton Manning | 1998 | Tennessee | 82%
|
| Michael Vick | 2001 | Virginia Tech | 78%
|
| Sam Bradford | 2010 | Oklahoma | 77%
|
| JaMarcus Russell | 2007 | LSU | 76%
|
| Carson Palmer | 2003 | USC | 72%
|
| Alex Smith | 2005 | Utah | 70%
|
| David Carr | 2002 | Fresno State | 64%
|
| Bo Jackson | 1986 | Auburn | 60%
|
| John Elway | 1983 | Stanford | 51%
|
| OJ Simpson | 1969 | USC | 50%
|
| Jake Long | 2008 | Michigan | 47%
|
| Troy Aikman | 1989 | UCLA | 46%
|
| Eric Fisher | 2013 | Central Michigan | 42%
|
| Keyshawn Johnson | 1996 | USC | 41%
|
| Orlando Pace | 1997 | Ohio State | 38%
|
| Tim Couch | 1999 | Kentucky | 36%
|
| Vinny Testaverde | 1987 | Miami (FL) | 34%
|
| Ki-Jana Carter | 1995 | Penn State | 34%
|
| Earl Campbell | 1978 | Texas | 34%
|
| Terry Bradshaw | 1970 | Louisiana Tech | 32%
|
| Mario Williams | 2006 | NC State | 31%
|
| Courtney Brown | 2000 | Penn State | 30%
|
| Drew Bledsoe | 1993 | Washington State | 29%
|
| Billy Sims | 1980 | Oklahoma | 22%
|
| Jim Plunkett | 1971 | Stanford | 20%
|
| Jeff George | 1990 | Illinois | 19%
|
| Paul Hornung | 1957 | Notre Dame | 18%
|
| Bruce Smith | 1985 | Virginia Tech | 18%
|
| Russell Maryland | 1991 | Miami (FL) | 17%
|
| Ernie Davis | 1962 | Syracuse | 17%
|
| Dan Wilkinson | 1994 | Ohio State | 16%
|
| Steve Emtman | 1992 | Washington | 16%
|
| Irving Fryar | 1984 | Nebraska | 14%
|
| George Rogers | 1981 | South Carolina | 14%
|
| Lee Roy Selmon | 1976 | Oklahoma | 12%
|
| Aundray Bruce | 1988 | Auburn | 11%
|
| Ricky Bell | 1977 | USC | 11%
|
| Billy Cannon | 1960 | LSU | 9%
|
| Bubba Smith | 1967 | Michigan State | 9%
|
| Ron Yary | 1968 | USC | 9%
|
| Jay Berwanger | 1936 | Chicago | 8%
|
| Tom Cousineau | 1979 | Ohio State | 8%
|
| Steve Bartkowski | 1975 | Cal | 7%
|
| Kenneth Sims | 1982 | Texas | 7%
|
| Tom Harmon | 1941 | Michigan | 6%
|
| Ed Jones | 1974 | Tennessee State | 6%
|
| Walt Patulski | 1972 | Notre Dame | 5%
|
| Leon Hart | 1950 | Notre Dame | 5%
|
| Angelo Bertelli | 1944 | Notre Dame | 5%
|
| Chuck Bednarik | 1949 | Penn | 5%
|
| Tommy Nobis | 1966 | Texas | 5%
|
| Terry Baker | 1963 | Oregon State | 4%
|
| John Matuszak | 1973 | Tampa | 4%
|
| Tucker Frederickson | 1965 | Auburn | 3%
|
| Charley Trippi | 1945 | Georgia | 3%
|
| Frank Sinkwich | 1943 | Georgia | 3%
|
| Harry Gilmer | 1948 | Alabama | 2%
|
| Frank Dancewicz | 1946 | Notre Dame | 2%
|
| Kyle Rote | 1951 | SMU | 2%
|
| Gary Glick | 1956 | Colorado A&M | 1%
|
| Harry Babcock | 1953 | Georgia | 1%
|
| Corbett Davis | 1938 | Indiana | 1%
|
| Randy Duncan | 1959 | Iowa | 1%
|
| Sam Francis | 1937 | Nebraska | 1%
|
| Bob Fenimore | 1947 | Oklahoma A&M | 1%
|
| George Shaw | 1955 | Oregon | 1%
|
| King Hill | 1958 | Rice | 1%
|
| Bobby Garrett | 1954 | Stanford | 1%
|
| Ki Aldrich | 1939 | TCU | 1%
|
| George Cafego | 1940 | Tennessee | 1%
|
| Dave Parks | 1964 | Texas Tech | 1%
|
| Tommy Mason | 1961 | Tulane | 1%
|
| Bill Wade | 1952 | Vanderbilt | 1%
|
| Bill Dudley | 1942 | Virginia | 1%
|