| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| "I hope your apple pie is freakin' worth it!" | Dean | 95%
|
| "Wait there's no such thing as unicorns?" | Sam | 95%
|
| "We know a little about a lot of things; just enough to make us dangerous" | Dean | 70%
|
| "No he's not on any flat bread" | Castiel | 67%
|
| "I found a liquor store and I drank it" | Castiel | 65%
|
| "Spent it on ammo" | John | 52%
|
| "I was drunk. It was comic-con." | Charlie | 51%
|
| "Good morning Vietnam" | Lucifer | 46%
|
| "I've been inside your brother, we're practically family" | Crowley | 34%
|
| "I don't get out of bed for three grand" | Bela | 29%
|
| "You're a great big bag of dicks" | Gabriel | 26%
|
| "Best purchase I've made since Dick Cheney." | Crowley | 25%
|
| "Ed, you've got to go be gay for that poor dead intern" | Harry the Ghostfacer | 24%
|
| "Oh, I am so not in the mood for this. I've just been shot!" | Meg | 23%
|
| "Even you have to admit I'm- I'm awesome!" | Ruby | 23%
|
| "I always trust you. And I always end up screwed" | Kevin | 22%
|
| "Brains trumps legs, apparently" | Bobby | 19%
|
| "Is that a molar. I have a molar in my hair... its been a really stressful day..." | Chuck | 19%
|
| "You turned yourself into a freak. A monster. And now you're not gonna bite? I'm sorry, but that is honestly adorable." | Lilith | 18%
|
| "You can go straight back to hell you ugly bitch" | Ellen | 17%
|
| The "End is nigh, the Apocalypse is coming, kiddo. To a theater near you." | Zachariah | 17%
|
| "Damn right REO. Kevin Cronin sings from the heart" | Jo | 16%
|
| "Just because he created us doesn't mean he can toy with us, like playthings" | Lucifer | 15%
|
| "Well, here is one for the list of dumbest things ever. Summon the angel who wants to kill you" | Balthazar | 12%
|
| "I know the difference between fantasy and reality." | Becky | 8%
|
| "I know its hard to believe, but I haven't always been this cute and cuddly" | Benny | 7%
|