| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Left Ted at the alter | Stella Zinman | 98%
|
| The one he always wanted | Robin Scherbatsky | 97%
|
| One of the three women Barney arranges for Ted through online dating.* | Robyn | 97%
|
| Cupcake* | Victoria | 94%
|
| Left The Captain for Ted | Zoey Pierson | 89%
|
| The Mother | Tracy McConnell Mosby | 80%
|
| Dated Ted in college, but always cheated on him* | Karen | 64%
|
| Ted met her online (World of Warcraft). She turned out to be on the wrong side of the "Hot/Crazy" scale.** | Blah Blah | 47%
|
| Robin's perky co-anchor on "Come On, Get Up New York"* | Becky | 42%
|
| The cousin of the girl who left The Captain. She was beautiful, but naive. Oh _____.... ** | Honey | 41%
|
| Last girlfriend before meeting the Mother | Jeanette Peterson | 40%
|
| Ex-Girlfriend in the episode when Ted's then-girlfriend makes him get rid of everything he kept from his exes. | Jeannie Radford | 40%
|
| Ted's co-worker on the New Year's Eve Limo Date* | Marybeth | 35%
|
| One-night-stand from MacLaren's who left a pineapple before using the fire escape.* | Trudy | 35%
|
| She was a paralegal, but Barney told Ted she was a prostitute* | Mary | 34%
|
| Ted broke up with her on her answering machine!* | Natalie | 30%
|
| The girl who had done it all: climbed Everest, donated a kidney, and was just too good to be true. She even had her own website. | Janet McIntyre | 23%
|
| A PhD candidate who happened to be The Mother's roommate* | Cindy | 22%
|
| Vegetarian who threw red paint on a chef** | Strawberry | 22%
|
| They went on a blind date... only realize they had done that with each 7 years before* | Jen | 20%
|
| Ted got her number in MacLaren's, but Barney changed it in Ted's phone to his number! Hilarity ensued...* | Holli | 19%
|
| She convinced Ted to get a tattoo* | Amy | 17%
|
| The Slutty Pumpkin* | Naomi | 17%
|
| Ted and Barney had a bet to see who could "bang" her first | Stacey Gusar | 15%
|
| Ted tried "The Naked Man" on her* | Vicky | 15%
|
| One of the "Random Skanks" that Lily complained about. She ruined the cake at Lily's 32nd Birthday Party* | Amanda | 14%
|
| Way too talkative* | Cathy | 13%
|
| Ted lost his virginity to her.* | Molly | 13%
|
| Ted was looking for her emotional baggage* | Royce | 12%
|
| Barney's half-sister* | Carly Whittaker | 11%
|
| One of the three women Barney arranges for Ted through online dating.* | Holly | 11%
|
| College gal pal of the girl above. The pair go up to Ted's apartment where he ALMOST won the Threeway Belt.* | Rachel | 10%
|
| After his wedding, Barney offered Ted his choice of three women. Ted chose her.* | Cassie | 6%
|
| Ex-Girlfriend in the episode when Ted's then-girlfriend makes him get rid of everything he kept from his exes. | Lauren Stein | 6%
|
| One of Barney's "Phone Girls" who is a violinist, gourmet cook, and can quote every line from "Caddyshack." But is she a Rabbit? or a Duck?* | Natalia | 5%
|
| Ex-Girlfriend in the episode when Ted's then-girlfriend makes him get rid of everything he kept from his exes.* | Carla | 4%
|
| Ex-Girlfriend in the episode when Ted's then-girlfriend makes him get rid of everything he kept from his exes. | Allison Moses | 3%
|
| Random girl from the episode "Return of the Shirt"* | Jackie | 3%
|
| One of the three women Barney arranges for Ted through online dating.* | Lizbeth | 2%
|