| # | Teams | Years | Pitcher | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 | Angels, Astros, Rangers | 1973 (2), 1974, 1975, 1981, 1990, 1991 | Nolan Ryan | 99%
|
| 3 | Tigers, Astros | 2007, 2011, 2019 | Justin Verlander | 95%
|
| 4 | Dodgers | 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965 | Sandy Koufax | 90%
|
| 2 | Mariners, Diamondbacks | 1990, 2004 | Randy Johnson | 74%
|
| 2 | Nationals | 2015 (2) | Max Scherzer | 73%
|
| 2 | Phillies | 2010 (2) | Roy Halladay | 61%
|
| 3 | Indians | 1940, 1946, 1951 | Bob Feller | 59%
|
| 2 | Cubs | 2015, 2016 | Jake Arrieta | 59%
|
| 2 | Giants | 2013, 2014 | Tim Lincecum | 56%
|
| 2 | Americans | 1904, 1908 | Cy Young | 44%
|
| 2 | White Sox | 2007, 2009 | Mark Buehrle | 37%
|
| 2 | Giants | 1901, 1905 | Christy Mathewson | 34%
|
| 2 | A's | 1970, 1975* | Vida Blue | 31%
|
| 2 | Braves | 1960, 1961 | Warren Spahn | 31%
|
| 2 | Reds | 2012, 2013 | Homer Bailey | 21%
|
| 2 | Tigers, Phillies | 1958, 1964 | Jim Bunning | 19%
|
| 2 | Reds | 1938 (2) | Johnny Vander Meer | 19%
|
| 2 | Astros, A's | 2015, 2019 | Mike Fiers | 18%
|
| 2 | Dodgers, Red Sox | 1996, 2001 | Hideo Nomo | 17%
|
| 2 | Angels | 1984, 1990* | Mike Witt | 17%
|
| 2 | Cardinals | 1978, 1983 | Bob Forsch | 14%
|
| 2 | Astros | 1967, 1969 | Don Wilson | 11%
|
| 2 | Reds | 1965, 1969 | Jim Maloney | 11%
|
| 2 | Cubs | 1969, 1971 | Kent Holtzman | 11%
|
| 2 | Yankees | 1951 (2) | Allie Reynolds | 10%
|
| 2 | Naps | 1908, 1910 | Addie Joss | 9%
|
| 2 | Red Sox | 1916, 1918 | Dutch Leonard | 9%
|
| 2 | Braves | 1991*, 1994 | Kent Mercker | 8%
|
| 2 | Royals | 1973, 1974 | Steve Busby | 8%
|
| 2 | Expos | 1969, 1972 | Bill Stoneman | 7%
|
| 2 | Dodgers | 1952, 1956 | Carl Erskine | 7%
|
| 2 | White Sox | 1905, 1908 | Frank Smith | 6%
|
| 2 | Phillies, Mariners | 2003, 2012* | Kevin Millwood | 6%
|
| 2 | Detroit | 1952 (2) | Virgil Trucks | 5%
|