| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Blonde Slayer, Main Character | Buffy Summers | 100%
|
| First vampire with a soul, loved slayer first | Angel | 99%
|
| Second vampire with a soul, loved slayer second | Spike | 98%
|
| The witch of the group | Willow Rosenberg | 98%
|
| The watcher | Rupert Giles | 97%
|
| The civilian scoobie who loses an eye | Xander Harris | 96%
|
| Brunette Slayer, turned rogue | Faith Lehane | 94%
|
| Mean girl in high school, became "vision girl" | Cordelia Chase | 92%
|
| Former vengeance demon | Anya Christina Emmanuella Jenkins AKA Anyanka AKA Anya Emerson AKA Aud | 91%
|
| Werewolf, loves the witch | Daniel Osbourne | 89%
|
| Sister of the slayer, made from the slayer, The Key | Dawn Summers | 89%
|
| Second witch, girlfriend of red haired witch, killed by bullet | Tara Maclay | 88%
|
| Crazy vampire sired by #8, sired #9, can see the future | Drusilla | 83%
|
| "GI Joe", Part of the Initiative, loved the slayer | Riley Finn | 82%
|
| Mom of the slayer | Joyce Summers | 79%
|
| Slayer from Jamaica, throat slit | Kendra Young | 79%
|
| Blonde, "skanky" god searching for The Key | Glorificus | 75%
|
| Groupie of girl above, becomes a vampire | Harmony Kendall | 75%
|
| "From beneath you, it devours." | The First Evil | 64%
|
| "Crazy preacher man", agent of character above. | Caleb | 55%
|
| Original friend of #4 and #5, made into a vampire, staked by #5 | Jesse McNally | 34%
|
| Type of vampire that lives under the Hellmouth. | Turok-Han | 13%
|
| First potential slayer to walk into the Summers' home, later killed by preacher man | Molly | 9%
|
| First slayer, even though it was said she "had no speech, no name" | Sineya | 6%
|