| WAR | Position | Career | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 162.2 | RF | 1914–1935 | Babe Ruth | 96%
|
| 162.8 | LF | 1986–2007 | Barry Bonds | 96%
|
| 156.2 | CF | 1951–1973 | Willie Mays | 92%
|
| 110.3 | CF | 1951–1968 | Mickey Mantle | 86%
|
| 101.2 | 1B | 2001–2022 | Albert Pujols | 83%
|
| 151.4 | CF | 1905–1928 | Ty Cobb | 82%
|
| 117.4 | SS / 3B | 1994–2016 | Alex Rodriguez | 81%
|
| 113.7 | 1B | 1923–1939 | Lou Gehrig | 81%
|
| 121.8 | LF | 1939–1960 | Ted Williams | 80%
|
| 131.1 | SS | 1897–1917 | Honus Wagner | 77%
|
| 106.9 | 3B | 1972–1989 | Mike Schmidt | 68%
|
| 128.6 | OF / 1B | 1941–1963 | Stan Musial | 65%
|
| 127.3 | 2B | 1915–1937 | Rogers Hornsby | 57%
|
| 111.2 | LF | 1979–2003 | Rickey Henderson | 51%
|
| 100.6 | 2B | 1963–1984 | Joe Morgan | 50%
|
| 107.2 | RF | 1956–1976 | Frank Robinson | 49%
|
| 134.9 | CF | 1907–1928 | Tris Speaker | 48%
|
| 106.9 | 2B | 1896–1916 | Nap Lajoie | 43%
|
| 110.0 | RF | 1926–1937 | Mel Ott | 31%
|
| 124.2 | 2B | 1906–1930 | Eddie Collins | 28%
|
| 143.2 | RF | 1954–1976 | Henry Aaron | 22%
|