| WAR | Career | Pitcher | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 101.1 | 1988–2009 | Randy Johnson | 99%
|
| 167.8 | 1907–1927 | Walter Johnson | 99%
|
| 139.2 | 1984–2007 | Roger Clemens | 93%
|
| 81.7 | 2005– | Justin Verlander | 91%
|
| 83.9 | 1992–2009 | Pedro Martinez | 88%
|
| 106.6 | 1986–2006 | Greg Maddux | 86%
|
| 109.9 | 1967–1986 | Tom Seaver | 81%
|
| 89.2 | 1959–1975 | Bob Gibson | 78%
|
| 90.2 | 1965–1988 | Steve Carlton | 76%
|
| 106.7 | 1900–1916 | Christy Mathewson | 73%
|
| 106.8 | 1925–1941 | Lefty Grove | 72%
|
| 100.1 | 1942, 1946–1965 | Warren Spahn | 62%
|
| 119.7 | 1911–1930 | Grover Alexander | 61%
|
| 95.9 | 1964–1987 | Phil Niekro | 61%
|
| 94.5 | 1970–1992 | Bert Blyleven | 57%
|
| 90.0 | 1962–1983 | Gaylord Perry | 45%
|
| 84.1 | 1965–1983 | Fergie Jenkins | 34%
|
| 86.2 | 1948–1966 | Robin Roberts | 34%
|
| 82.8 | 1991–2008 | Mike Mussina | 27%
|
| 91.2 | 1901–1917 | Eddie Plank | 24%
|