Some "Eurekas" of Mathematics - Part Eleven

+11

Introduction / Preliminaries

This blog will use some topological terminology, but I try to keep everything at a basic level in terms of understandability.

The big result that I want to lead up to is this:

There is always a pair of antipodal points on the Earth that have the same exact temperature.

Some topological terms that will be used, such as homeomorphic, are mentioned in this blog. Check it out for more background information! And if you're unsure what the word antipodal means, this refers to antipodes, that is opposite points on a sphere, e.g., the North Pole and South Pole.

Brouwer's fixed-point theorem

A huge result from the early 20th century by Luitzen Egbertus Jan Brouwer, arguably the most important of his life's work, deals with fixed points. Today we call it the Brouwer fixed-point theorem. Brouwer initially proved this using topological invariance of degree. Personally I'm more familiar with it as a corollary to the Lefschetz fixed-point theorem, but for simplicity sake we'll bypass proving this statement in this blog. Here's the statement of the theorem:

For any continuous function f mapping a nonempty compact convex set to itself,
there is a point x 0 such that f ( x 0 ) = x 0 .

That is, if you continuously map a compact set like say a disk onto itself, there will always be at least one fixed point. Supposedly Brouwer received inspiration for this when he was mixing his coffee, which allows for a nice analogy: there's always a motionless particle on the surface when you stir your coffee.

Source:  Indagationes Mathematicae, 2018

An Application to Weather

As stated above, the interesting application we are focused on in this blog is how at some pair of antipodal points on Earth, the temperature is identical. In the image below, we see an example of two antipodal points that have the same temperature. I found this image online and I'm honestly not sure if the data is real or not, but let's just go with it and say it is.

Source: Scientific Gems

One important thing to note is that this will rely on the fact that temperature is "continuous", which I will handwave for now. I'm no meteorologist, so I don't know whether temperature discontinuities are possible, but a quick Google search told me that temperature is continuous. Plus it feels intuitive, so we'll go with it.

Now onto the proof that it is true. This proof won't be incredibly detailed as some of the details may be too technical. We'll also be operating under the assumption that Brouwer's fixed-point theorem is true, as we mentioned above. Proving that falls a bit out of the scope of this blog.

The Proof

We will approach this by employing a proof by contradiction. Thus, by means of contradiction, we assume that there exists a continuous map

f : S 2 → ℝ 2 such that f ( x ) ≠ f ( - x ) for all points x on the sphere, S 2 .
We then define a function g on the sphere as g ( x ) = f ( x ) - f ( - x ) ‖ f ( x ) - f ( - x ) ‖ Notice that this maps onto the unit circle S 1 . Therefore the restriction and projection of this map to the upper hemisphere, which is homeomorphic to a closed disk to h ( x ) = x + ϵ g ( x ) meets the conditions for the hypothesis of Brouwer's fixed-point theorem. Hence h( x 0 )= x 0 for some fixed point x 0 .
It then follows that g( x 0 )=0, meaning that for x 0 , f( x 0 )=f(- x 0 ), which is a contradiction. Therefore the negation of our original assumption must be true. ∎

Reflection

What do you think? I personally find some aspects of this fixed-point theorem to be intuitive, such as giving a simple stir to a coffee mug, but there are other aspects that seem more shocking. This concept of antipodal points can be applied also to other phenomena such as wind speeds or air pressure.

Another application to consider is one that was supposedly stated very similarly by Brouwer himself. In this application, consider two identical bedsheets, one a normal flat sheet and the other a fitted sheet that was initially the same size as the other sheet. This crumpled fitted sheet, when positioned exactly overtop the flat bedsheet, will have at least one point where the two sheets identically match up.

I believe the statement of Brouwer was actually very similar but instead about sheets of paper. See the image to the left!

14 Comments
+2
Level 69
Mar 4, 2025
finally part 11!
+1
Level 78
Mar 4, 2025
Hope you enjoy!
+2
Level 65
Mar 4, 2025
quite interesting, this just doesn't seem right, but i guess it is.
+2
Level 78
Mar 4, 2025
Which part(s)?
+1
Level 65
Mar 4, 2025
applying it to weather i would say
+1
Level 78
Mar 4, 2025
Yeah, it is kinda random or maybe even counter-intuitive
+2
Level 57
Mar 4, 2025
Once again an excellent entry in this series! I like the link you made with another of your blogs, that's cool to reuse elements that we learnt with you in the past.
+2
Level 78
Mar 4, 2025
Thank you for your kind words!

And you're right, it's always nice when the have a bit of overlapping with each other

+2
Level 61
Mar 4, 2025
What a nerd.

*heart*

+1
Level 78
Mar 4, 2025
Nerds unite?
+2
Level 75
Mar 4, 2025
You're also a nerd
+2
Level 61
Mar 5, 2025
First one I have read! Very interesting cathlete!
+1
Level 57
Apr 14, 2025
Cool
+1
Level 35
Apr 15, 2025
Cool