France, still a democracy ?

+6

European Elections

You might have heard of it. Last Sunday were held the European elections in every European country. For those of you who are not familiar with the way it works, let me tell you. Each country has a designated number of seats at the European Parliament. This number is proportional to the number of inhabitants each country has. Now, the Parliament is divided in 3 main sides :


- The left, social, humane and struggling for equality
- The right, fair, struggling for liberties and justice
- The center, which is a mix of both

Our current president, Emmanuel Macron, was elected in 2017 with a new party, from the center. He has been reelected on 2022. Since his election, France has witnessed a lot of dramatic events followed by a lot of dramatic protests. The popularity of Macron, which was skyrocketting as he was first elected, never stopped dropping through the years, due to his despising behaviour. Not only did he ignore the warnings, the claims and the complaints, but he also spat straight at those who tried to make him realize the facts. 

Anyway, that was just for the context. Usually the presidential majority always has the highest number of seats following an election. So, the odds were alledgedly all with the Renaissance Party (Macron's party). However, the polls were giving another party ahead of Renaissance (litterally, Renewal). That party is Rassemblement National (RN, litterally National Gathering). The RN is very controversial. Its former leaders were very problematic and that image got stuck to the party despite changing leaders ever since. Its electors are considered racists or even fascits by the left wing electors we'll talk about right after.


However, RN has done a huge job in polishing its image and their representatives (Jordan Bardella - Marine Le Pen) are well-known for their eloquences. And, on Sunday night, France learned that the RN had gathered 32% of the votes, meanwhile Renaissance did not even halve this number, with a tiny 14% of votes. Thunderstorm, the president lost. 

That could be the end of the story, but if it was, France would not be the funny country you know.

What happened next

Immediately, the reactions sparked all over social networks. Many left-wing youngsters, swarming on TikTok or Instagram, started launching hashtags to gather and organize massive vandalism "against the extreme right".


The left-wing was represented by Manon Aubry, and the party is called La France Insoumise (litterally The rebellious France). It was initially created by Jean-Luc Melenchon, a very famous politic figure, known for his wild reactions and statements. Just like the RN, he himself is very controversial. This party prides itself on being one of the great bearers of democracy because it gives some voice and power to the minorities. However, it is also known for having members proudly not recognizing the attacks on Israel, many of their members are on the verge of sounding antisemitic. Some are sued for embezzlment and some others for sexual assault. 

Anyway, since they are the so-called "preachers of democracy", many young people agree with their ideas. However, they are so good at manipulating, that a new doctrine has emerged : "right wing goes to hell". 

Thus, many of the right-wing votants have been threatened of death, of rape. Many infrastructures have been vandalized or destroyed, because known for being close to the right-wing in a way. In Angers, a quiet city at the west of France, a bar has been completely demolished after demonstrators rushed in after thery learned the boss had voted RN. 


There's plenty more to say, but my writing's already too orientated, so I'll just stop there for the moment. I just wonder how, France, the country of democracy, has turned into a country on the edge of a civil war between the left and the right. This country is undergoing a very clivant and divisive atmosphere, where one side is afraid to say what they think in fear ogf being threatened to death...

NB : I am initially not inclined to any party. I could vote left or wing, as long as it is an extreme. However, recent events have orientated me and I've tried my best through this article to recognize facts.

9 Comments
+2
Level 81
Jun 12, 2024
Just a small point, it is only members of the European Union that had a ballot, not all of Europe.

The French people are known for their laissez-faire attitude to life but where politics are involved it is very much a case of "Vive La Revolution"

Let's hope the best party wins!

+1
Level 57
Jun 12, 2024
And to be exatct, it's important to specify that not all EU MS vote on Sunday.
+4
Level 57
Jun 12, 2024
Well, I understand that's difficult, especially in such a situation, but this blog is definitely super mega oriented.

Also, why only talking extreme while Renaissance, LR, PS and others are also concerned a lot by the current events? Even at extremes, mentioning Reconquête or even the NPA would have been necessary in my humble opinion.

+6
Level 57
Jun 12, 2024
Also, the title of the blog is pretty clickbait since that's at the same time not really what the blog is about and not truly the debate in the current situation.
+4
Level 59
Jun 12, 2024
As baptistegorce said, I think you should choose a better title for your blog because the current one doesn't cover exactly what you are saying here. You could try something like "What is happening these days in french politics?", if i can give ideas.

Also, if you want my opinion about it, your essay is indeed really subjective. You are clearly minimizing Rassemblement National's defaults, and developing and insisting on La France Insoumise's ones. Also some statements are wrong, like the "doctrine" (as you are calling it) is more like "far-right goes to hell", which is not the same. You are also not talking about other parties (as baptistegorce also mentionned) while i think they are very important in this situation, because the winner party of the future legislative elections will probably depend on alliances with other right wing or left wing parties.

+4
Level 59
Jun 12, 2024
More globally, i feel like someone who doesn't know at all about french politics will think that La France Insoumise are the bad guys and Rassemblement National are the good ones, while it's definitely more complicated and mixed than that.
+2
Level 69
Jun 13, 2024
I agree with baptistegorce, the name is very clickable. I doubt at all whether the elections to the European Parliament of Le Pen's party will change anything. I remember two years ago, another "fascist" and "subversive of democracy and European unity" Giorgia Meloni came to power in Italy, who did not change anything in the general policy of Italy (I think she only shouted a few loud statements and began to justify and nurture fascists in Italy little by little). I wonder how different Le Pen is from her, I think not much. Besides, speaking of the name, don't you think that Macron and his company have already tried to do this with his mess in the country and Napoleonic ambitions?
+3
Level 59
Jun 13, 2024
Well, I think this is a well-written blog that try to present equally both part of french political spectrum.

Your blog is clearly oriented (for instance, saying that right wing is "fair" but not the left one), but you don't try to hide it so I am fine with it. I prefer neutral political analysis but everyone should be able to express their thoughs, as long as there are respectuous (and I think you are).

You also made a good job contextualizing the recent events of french politics, bravo !

However I think there are some misinformations in it. Notwithstanding,I don't think you are malicious, so let me explain briefly what I'll change.

First, saying that LFI is antisemitic and do not recognizing attacks on Israel. This is completely wrong, as LFI clearly denounce Hamas attacks but also want justice for Gaza.

Second, the criticism again the Israelian government can be antisionist and this is completely different that antisemitism.

+2
Level 59
Jun 13, 2024
Also, even if you oriented your blog, maybe you are not fair with the left wing. If you accuse LFI representant of embezzlment or sexual assault, you should do the same for the RN (also known for embezzlment : https://www.lesechos.fr/politique-societe/politique/soupcons-de-detournement-de-fonds-europeens-marine-le-pen-et-le-rn-seront-juges-a-partir-du-30-septembre-2085523) and explain the reaction of other party members. Also give some example.

Else, you generalize the comportement of some individuals to all the party sympatisant. This is the same thing when all RN sympatisant are categorized as fascits.

Last but not least, you got a lot of comment telling you to talk about other notable party (LR, PS, etc) but I don't think you have to, as you just want to write a small tribune about the europeans. Maybe mentionning the PS could have be a good idea (this is the left party with most vote for the european election), but not mandatory.