There is only room for ten quarterbacks. Brady, Favre, Elway, Marino, Manning, Montana, and Staubach are all better than Kelly for sure, and I never saw Unitas play, but most conversations put him right near the top of the list. That leaves Otto Graham and Sammy Baugh, each of whom may or may not be better than Kelly, but the list wants to cover all periods of the game to seem more credible, so they're going to include a few really old guys. Brees didn't make it either, and he's probably than Kelly too.
Gates definetly should've been on here. No way is he not a top 5 tight end ever. Kelce also deserves some love, but his career is a little too short. Come on dude.
I see that you're paying tribute to many old players from the old football era, but some of this is outrageous. Running backs: Clark, Moore, and Motley? Who? What about Faulk, James, Peterson, Tomlinson, Dorsett, Allen, Davis, Harris, etc. Tarkenton, Warner, Starr, and Brees could've made QBs, but that's fine. Then WR: Hirsch, Warfield, can't be here. Owens, Bruce, Reed, Ward, Brown, Irvin, Carter, Johnson, maybe? And the DEFENSE! Atkins, Hewitt, Buchanan, White, Hendricks, Schmidt, Christiansen, Houston, Tunnell can't be here. What about Sapp, Strahan, Peppers, Jason and Sean Taylor, Youngblood, Davis, Singletary, Urlacher, Nitschke, Willis, Law, Atwater, Woodson, Revis, Polamalu, Renfro, Bailey, etc. This list disappoints on so many levels. Nice try, Quizmaster.
Actually, this is the official NFL Top 100 list made by the NFL itself. Sorry that you don't know any players from before the 2000s but most of these players deserve to be on here. I agree that some should've been on here over others, but they aren't gonna have the same opinion as everyone.
The running backs he listed were all more deserving than Lenny Moore and Marion motley. Can you disagree that Marcus Allen and laidanian Tomlinson are top RBs?
Bo Jackson was good for 3 years and then got hurt. Sorry that you only know NFL players by their madden rating. Watch them play before you say Bo "3 Years Jackson
Christiansen is on this list but Antonio Gates isn't. Wow. I also remember Vinitary as a colts player to end his career, and I got him mixed up with Gostkowski. Definetly needs some working on, and needs some updates.
The running backs he listed were all more deserving than Lenny Moore and Marion motley. Can you disagree that Marcus Allen and laidanian Tomlinson are top RBs?
We got Dutch Clark
wut
- Lenny Moore, Marion motley, etc. over LAIDANIAN TOMLINSON
- Hubbard, etc. over ORLANDO PACE
- I hope others may entail the other horrors I have witnessed