Jail is to kitchen - there's no connection, so there is no analogy. Literally any word fits. It's like dog is to tree as Dalmation is to oak. So anything works - rudder, crow's nest, anchor, etc.
No. Anything doesn't work. Jail is connected to brig because it's the same thing. So, what's the same thing as a kitchen but on a ship?
Your example IS ambiguous as you just took one breed of dog with nothing specific to it, so yes, the answer could be any type of tree. But not so with the clue in the quiz.
I don't think that there is a steadfast rule that says that analogies have to read as definitions. That's how they are most commonly shown, but i don't think that's a rule.
A brig is specific to the US Navy in the context of meaning a jail onboard a ship. However, a brig is also a name of a type of ship, as is a galley. Until I looked up possible other relationships between jail and brig, I only knew of brig as a type of sailing ship, which is actually the derivation of the jail term when the US navy started using old sailing ships as military jails. A very US-centric analogy that is a poor option for a quiz that has vastly more non-US site users than US users.
Yes, this needs to be changed. It would be more apt if it were Brig is to Jail as Galley is to Kitchen. As it is, as jm says, the words Jail and Kitchen have no connection at all so it doesn't work.
This clue really doesn't track - the point of the analogy pairs in this quiz is that the relationships are the same between component parts. For instance, A relates to Ampere the same way V relates to ___; the first component is the first letter (and common abbreviation) for the second component. Mafia relates to Sicily the same way Yakuza relates to ___; the first component is an organized crime entity in the second component.
That pattern doesn't hold for the Jail/Kitchen clue. What exactly is the relationship between a jail and a kitchen? I guess a kitchen is a room in a typical jail? Ok, so then what is the relationship between a brig and _____? They are both rooms in a ship - but one is not contained within the other.
The relationships are not the same within each pair, so this clue does not fit the pattern established in this quiz.
Yeah, that one wasn't really a great analogy. I think its saying a week is a small part of a century and the [current] weather is a small part of overall climate.
No, it doesn't have to do with the letters. Weather pertains to the atmospheric conditions in the short term (week). Climate pertains to atmospheric conditions in the long term (century).
Weather is short term, climate is long term. It's actually pretty directly applicable: looking at the last week tells you the weather, but looking over the last century tells you the climate.
Or, is it just pointing out that the London Underground is a metro system
Because I've heard London Underground, Tube, etc., but don't remember hearing a colloquial or formal name for the Paris metro system in my everyday culture.
But my first try was chevron. Should that not also be acceptable?
Jail is to Kitchen as Brig is to _____
It should be Jail is to Brig as Kitchen is to ___
Analogies should read as definitions: A jail is called a brig on a ship, just like the kitchen on a ship is called the ____
(I got the answer - no spoilers ;-)
Your example IS ambiguous as you just took one breed of dog with nothing specific to it, so yes, the answer could be any type of tree. But not so with the clue in the quiz.
These definitional ones shouldn't be mixed. Why not "analogies" like "Jail is to Kitchen as Carcel is to [Cocina]"?
"Vox is to Pax as Voice is to [Peace]" would be awful as well, since the first pair aren't related in any meaningful way.
"Pisces is to Cancer as fish is to [Crab]" again would be the wrong way round.
A-Z / alpha-omega is a nice one, as they're related both ways and could be expressed either way round.
That pattern doesn't hold for the Jail/Kitchen clue. What exactly is the relationship between a jail and a kitchen? I guess a kitchen is a room in a typical jail? Ok, so then what is the relationship between a brig and _____? They are both rooms in a ship - but one is not contained within the other.
The relationships are not the same within each pair, so this clue does not fit the pattern established in this quiz.
Can someone explain that to me?
Or, is it just pointing out that the London Underground is a metro system
Because I've heard London Underground, Tube, etc., but don't remember hearing a colloquial or formal name for the Paris metro system in my everyday culture.