Somehow I read the comment from clivey in a muppet voice. I guess it was the emphasis on the end of the words and dragging it on to the next word (while still being staccato), (like: bu -Ti -Tiss, for but it is) must ve triggered a memory.
I disagree with inclusion of London. The county of Greater London, whose population you show, is NOT a city. The true City of London (the area around St. Paul's Cathedral & Bank of England) has a population of only about 7,000, and is not a part of the county. However, the county DOES include the City of Westminster, but that certainly does not make the top 20 list. So please revise.
The boundary for Greater London, that was used here, was made in the 60s and London has sprawled out a load since then. After what happened to Wessex, no-one has re-drawn the line.
London hasn't really grown much outward post-1965 (the boundaries of which deliberately excluded parts of the urban area as they didn't want to be part of London) - the creation of the Green Belt in 1947 put an end to that.
No, from the London Government Act 1963 (that created Greater London) section 3(i)(a): "As from 1st April 1965 no part of Greater London shall form part of any administrative county".
Greater London was removed from the county system in 1965, not made as a new county.
It was, excluding the City of London, created as a county in 1997, for the purposes of the Lieutenancies Act of that year.
Love Glasgow's coat of arms in the picture box! The bird that never flew, the tree that never grew, the bell that never rang and the fish that never swam.
I'm curious about the figures in this quiz as many don't equate to what is given in the 2021 data in the referenced source. In fact the only ones that do are Edinburgh and Glasgow. There seem to be some real anomalies too, e.g. Manchester and Liverpool are larger cities than Bristol for instance but Bristol appears above them in this quiz (though not in the source). Living near Bristol and having been to Manchester and Liverpool on many occasions the relative sizes are easy to see.
Actually it's not - else Wakefield would be on it, and Leeds would be much bigger! It's built-up-areas. Which can still be a little arbitrary in where an urban area is subdivided (typically due to administrative boundaries).
The 2021 census figure for the City of Leeds is 811,953 - you are missing nearly 300,000 people, presumably because you are incorrectly excluding surrounding towns that are inside the city limits. City-proper for every city eligible for this quiz (for smaller cities this might not be the case), except London, is the local government district it's part of - those are the entities that are the keeper of the city status. You've gone with settlement population or something - not city population.
There's other errors in these figures too, but not as blatant as Leeds missing over a third of its population. Plus there's the 350k Wakefield missing.
All I know if that the UK government is poor, very poor indeed, at reporting population numbers in a clear way.
A previous version of this quiz included Wakefield. The howls of protest were intense.
I don't think it's possible to find numbers that will satisfy everyone. I'd recommend emailing the owner of citypopulation.de from which we draw our data. Perhaps he or she can explain the missing subtleties.
Looking further, the data this quiz is using is 'built up area' data (save for London) - the description of the dataset on citypopulation.de says clearly that that's what it is using. I'd suggest changing the description to reflect that reality - it's not city population at all.
Northampton is thankfully just too small to be on this quiz to avoid having the issue that this quiz is talking about the largest settlements, rather than cities in the UK sense.
I'd be happy with whatever dataset you use, as long as you correctly say what dataset you are using. Where I'm not completely satisfied is that you've tried to fob me off and blame the sources, and then go on to say you've changed the quiz for those outraged by facts. Why not change it to match the facts! The easiest way would be to replace 'city population' with 'built-up area population' in the description!
Great quiz but needs an update! Both Sunderland and Doncaster should be on here as they have been given city status and based on the last census (2021), both have a larger population than Southampton and Derby!
Doncaster or Sunderland being larger than Derby or Southampton is actually not true. I live in Derby, and whilst it's not a big city, it's population is larger than Doncaster or Sunderland. What you might be referring to is Doncaster's or Sunderland's metropolitan population, which are a different metric altogether. This is going by the built-up area or urban population, and looking at the 2021 census figures, Doncaster is 113.5k (not the metropolitan borough of South Yorkshire, which is over 300k), whilst Sunderland is 168k (not the metropolitan borough of Tyne and Wear, which is 274k). What further complicates the issue is that when referring to metropolitan population, Derby is combined with Nottingham, like Sunderland for Newcastle or Doncaster for Sheffield, but is still its own unitary authority rather than a metropolitan borough.
or maybe my brain just lacks oxygen..
Greater London was removed from the county system in 1965, not made as a new county.
It was, excluding the City of London, created as a county in 1997, for the purposes of the Lieutenancies Act of that year.
Edit, yep my brain clearly hasnt had enough oxygen today yet..
There's other errors in these figures too, but not as blatant as Leeds missing over a third of its population. Plus there's the 350k Wakefield missing.
A previous version of this quiz included Wakefield. The howls of protest were intense.
I don't think it's possible to find numbers that will satisfy everyone. I'd recommend emailing the owner of citypopulation.de from which we draw our data. Perhaps he or she can explain the missing subtleties.
Northampton is thankfully just too small to be on this quiz to avoid having the issue that this quiz is talking about the largest settlements, rather than cities in the UK sense.
I'd be happy with whatever dataset you use, as long as you correctly say what dataset you are using. Where I'm not completely satisfied is that you've tried to fob me off and blame the sources, and then go on to say you've changed the quiz for those outraged by facts. Why not change it to match the facts! The easiest way would be to replace 'city population' with 'built-up area population' in the description!