I agree because in technical terms, there is no such position as Line Backer, Wide Receiver and Running Back. They are a class of position, but the positions for the Running Back class are either letters (A, B etc) or Tail Back, Half Back and Full Back. Also with Receivers, they are lettered as X and Y and Z. If you have a 5 receiver set, you would not say you have 5 wide receivers. For Line Backers, you'd have Middle, Outside, etc.
There's nothing wrong with the terms linebacker, running back and wide receiver. They are all "technically" correct.
For different offenses, formations and teams, different names will be used to differentiate between different positions and roles within these more generalised names given to the positions.
The quiz doesn't need to account for all the variations because not all teams follow the same naming conventions. The quiz is good as it is.
Wrong. A placekicker is not the holder, it is the kicker. Not a common term, but should be accepted for kicker. Although why one would guess "Place Kicker" for "K" is beyond me.
Not every possible name for every position is represented here - these are just the most common. I would argue that FL and NB don't belong here either.
Sort of like a slot receiver, but lines up more in the backfield closer to the ball. .... the player then typically flanks to the outsides -- the area the wide receivers have vacated. ... It's designed to create mismatches in man defenses and find holes in zone coverage.
I think the point is, if you asked said player what position they played, practically no one would say "flanker" or "nickel back". They would say "wide receiver" or "defensive back".
A flanker is another name for a wide receiver, particularly the receivers furthest away from the ball. The Z-receiver usually is not considered a flanker.
flanker is a sort of running back/wide receiver combo. Usually a running back who lines up as a wide receiver occasionally. Think Reggie Bush, Dexter McCluster, etc.
This is also wrong. A Flanker is basically a wide receiver who lines up off the line of scrimmage. Jerry Rice was a Flanker. The only time you would ever really hear the term is when the offense is lined up in a standard Pro Set; 2 Receivers and 1 TE with the receivers on opposite sides. The receiver opposite the TE is the Split End, and the other receiver is the Flanker. If the Flanker would line up on the same side as the Split End in a Slot Formation, then people often refer to that receiver as a Slot Receiver (which has become the more modern term).
A flanker is a wide receiver. In a standard 2 WR formation, the flanker will line up on the same side of the formation as the tight end, typically off of the line of scrimmage. He will "flank" the TE, hence flanker. Conversely, the other WR will be referred to as the split end. The SE will line up on the opposite side of the formation of the TE and FL, normally on the line of scrimmage.
You could separate wide receiver into flanker (which you have) and split end. Also, coaches will refer to the strong side, middle, and weak side linebackers in a 4-3 as Sam, Mike, and Will. Hence, "53's the Mike! Omaha! Omaha! hut!"
I would think that if you're going to accept situational positions (nose tackle, nickelback, flanker, etc.) you should accept things like H-Backs (tight ends that line up in the backfield and are used as fullbacks, Gronk does this often), slotbacks (running backs in the option, used by teams like Georgia Tech and Navy mostly), among others.
Nosetackle is arguably a real position and not just situational. Unlike DTs that line up on either side of the ball, the NT really does line up directly over the center. Gronk is still a TE, just one that is versatile and is used in different ways.
The correct positions for Running Backs would be Halfback and Fullback. A Tailback is just a Halfback that is lined up in an I-formation. In modern terms, you can just stick with Running Back and Fullback. All other terms are obsolete.
Linebackers are separated by Inside and Outside; they are two very different positions. I would have ILB and OLB as different positions.
Nickelback isn't a position. A team will play a 3rd Corner Back when they are in a Nickel Defense, and that player is sometimes referred to as the Nickel Corner or Nickel Back, but nobody ever refers to themselves as the Nickel Back.
And Flanker is indeed a position. It is generally a wide receiver that does not line up on the line of scrimmage (as opposed to a Split End that does). The terms Split End (SE) and Flanker (FL) are not often used anymore, but if you are going to have one you should have the other.
Lots of technical debates previously about positions. As an occasional watcher only, I think all positions for which players are SPECIFICALLY chosen/selected should count. Thus, PR should definitely be included, along with ST specialist - but no team drafts a holder - the back-up QB gets it by default. OLB & ILB should be split, HB included, FL & NB dropped. My 10 cents worth!
Nobody has used the term "flanker" since the penny farthing fell out of favor. The term has been "slot receiver" for decades. Usually there are two wide receivers, one on each extreme. The slot receiver is the third receiver, usually positioned between the left receiver and left tackle.
Interesting, but not surprising, that this quiz has generated so much discussion amongst football fans. Over the years, the game has changed and hybrid positions have come into being. Very few teams use a "flanker" anymore - a position derived from rugby - and instead use assorted positions as "wideouts" or wide receiver. "Nose tackle" was a position created when the 3-4 defensive scheme was developed, while "nickleback" was created when teams stuck a third defensive halfback on some obvious passing downs. "Cornerback" is a name for a defensive halfback who plays on one side of the field. The quiz does not mention "Split End" or "Slot Back", and "Halfbacks" are now called "Runningbacks" while the roll of "Fullback" has largely changed to mean a running back who primarily blocks. "PlaceKicker" is sometimes used to differentiate a "Kicker" from a "Punter" largely depending on what the play by play person wants to say.
Hey Deebo Samuel though, where are we putting him? I heard he made a name a new name for his position: Wide Back. Obviously not official yet, hopefully it will be, it's like the coolest position ever.
Any specific reason punt returner isn't included? Also, I know it's not but a position (is flanker though?), but put defensive back in, it might trip people up and as stated above, linebacker isn't technically a position,
For different offenses, formations and teams, different names will be used to differentiate between different positions and roles within these more generalised names given to the positions.
The quiz doesn't need to account for all the variations because not all teams follow the same naming conventions. The quiz is good as it is.
I can't believe I missed linebacker, because my son was a huge baby and I call him my future linebacker!
Linebackers are separated by Inside and Outside; they are two very different positions. I would have ILB and OLB as different positions.
Nickelback isn't a position. A team will play a 3rd Corner Back when they are in a Nickel Defense, and that player is sometimes referred to as the Nickel Corner or Nickel Back, but nobody ever refers to themselves as the Nickel Back.
And Flanker is indeed a position. It is generally a wide receiver that does not line up on the line of scrimmage (as opposed to a Split End that does). The terms Split End (SE) and Flanker (FL) are not often used anymore, but if you are going to have one you should have the other.