Not to take anything away from Williams, but many of the other guys on that list also missed time during the war, including Dimaggio, Gordon and Mize. ... So all of their numbers would be greater as well.
Trebek's comment (below) just revealed why I nearly missed Mays. It accepted "M-a-y" for Lee May while I was attempting to enter "M-a-y-s". I never caught that it didn't fill in the player I thought it was filling in. I just started by carpet-bombing Ruth, Aaron and Mays.
Nelson Cruz?!?! I was wondering how I could forget what superstar is second this decade in home runs, and then I saw it was Cruz...you never hear about him. The Pacific Northwest gets absolutely no attention.
Seeing that the top two most commonly guessed answers are Alex Rodriguez and Barry Bonds, I'm not sure this logic checks out. If anything, a major PED suspension should make someone MORE notorious as a power hitter.
I missed Cruz because I don't really associate him with the Mariners that much--he only played for them for 4 years. He was with the Rangers for longer (though split across two different decades).
That doesn't make sense in this quiz though, because it's only ranking players against players who played in the same decade as each other, and therefore mostly under the same conditions. It makes sense to claim Babe Ruth's home runs mean less than Hank Aaron's because Babe Ruth hit his homers against a diminished talent pool, but it is perfectly valid to compare Ruth's home run numbers to those of other players from the 20's because they played in the same segregated conditions with the same talent pool.
Let's not forget the juiced ball era, or the amphetamine era. But the records from the 1980s (not counting 1987) and the era from 2005-2014 are still clean maybe.
I missed Cruz because I don't really associate him with the Mariners that much--he only played for them for 4 years. He was with the Rangers for longer (though split across two different decades).
For some reason for Matt Olson it requires a full name whereas for all other players it accepts last name only.
Marcus Semien should be listed as Blue Jays because he has hit more homers for them than he did for the Rangers or Athletics this decade.