Good quiz. Didn't realize that Old Boy (2003) was such a popular film. I think I'm going to pass on seeing the Spike Lee remake and just download the original.
The premise and the ending were both absurd. Some of the actions sequences were inventive, but in my opinion this didn't make up for the rest. Particularly the ending. I mean, I won't spoil it, but wth?
Wow. Insterstellar is that high up the list? I really need to see that. I've been meaning to. Most of these movies are very good. Though upon seeing how highly it was rated I decided to check out the Korean original version of Old Boy- and it was completely awful. Everything else on this list that I've seen was good or great except maybe The Green Mile.
I saw it. I thought it was pretty good, though not the 12th best movie of all time. And I wish they didn't have to keep explaining basic physics, as if astronauts and scientists would need to do that, but I understand that the average audience member would have been lost without those explanations.
I think Interstellar is a good movie, but not thaaat good. In my opinion it would rank Top 500, but never Top 35 as seen on IMDB.
Some I think are good but overrated: The usual suspects, American history X, Whiplash, The pianist, The prestige, Requiem for a Dream, Eternal sunshine and Amadeus.
For me The Prestige is absolutely brilliant and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind might be the single most poignant film ever made about the aftermath of a bad breakup.
At least Tom Hanks can be seen as the lead actor for TS3. I got stumped on "Paul Reiser" even though I've seen Aliens a bunch of times. He's a key character, but really, should have just listed Sigourney Weaver there again (even though she's listed for Alien).
I agree that it's a bit inconsistent, but I don't think I would have gotten seven samurai if they named an actor from the film. When I saw Akira Kurosawa I was able to get it pretty easily.
I did not read the instructions correctly and was trying to pick the most popular rentals. I missed with guesses of Avatar, Titanic, Speed, Mission Impossible, Jerry Maguire, Apollo 13, Unforgiven, Deer Hunter, Animal House, Top Gun, the Big Lebowski, Batman Begins, Gangs of New York, Field of Dreams. It would be interesting to see a quiz about the most streamed or rented movies rather than those with the highest ratings on Netflix.
Please come check out my top 100 version, Imdb's version is a great list, but it does not take in account of much older movies, my list is a difficult, and accurate top 100 movies of all time list!
Surprised and disappointed that Gone With The Wind isn't on the list. As for what (in my opinion) shouldn't be, I could name quite a few, but I don't want to start a whole thing!
I made a quiz for the brand new "80 best-directed Films" list according to the Directors Guild of America : http://www.jetpunk.com/user-quizzes/71167/the-80-best-directed-films-directors-guild-of-america
Nice quiz. IMDB's list is weird, but it is what it is. No sign of Some Like it Hot, Metropolis, and countless other great movies, but still this is fun to do. There are some truly odd choices, but I guess they have an enthusiastic fan base which rates them on IMDB.
Shawshank Redemption deserves its place at the top. It's also great to see one of the greatest directors ever, Akira Kurosawa, getting at least some recognition. Seeing Chan-Wook Park's Oldboy here is really heartwarming, as is seeing so many Studio Ghibli films. And Chaplin - who doesn't love Chaplin?
It's a shame that none of films by Andrzej Wajda, Pedro Almodóvar, Kim Ki-Duk, Terry Gilliam or Wong-Kar Wai - just to name a few - make the list. Jean-Pierre Jeunet does, but honestly, I'd choose Delicatessen over Amélie any day.
Some of my all-time favourite movies that I would include here are: The Big Lebowski, The Crow, Lady Vengeance, Birdcage Inn and Lady Snowblood.
Given the demographic that populates so much of IMDB, I'm surprised the Big Lebowski isn't on here. It belongs with many great movies that also didn't make the list, but I feel like the Coen brothers would fit right in among these movies. Frankly, I'm surprised Fargo and No Country for Old Men aren't here as well.
Yeah, they have favorite directors. There's a moment there where I just started typing all the Kurosawa, Kubrick, Nolan, and Hitchcock films I could think of.
Also, just in case anyone is taking recs from the comment section, I'd strongly recommend City of God. That's a great movie.
Surprising that no Wes Anderson film makes the list, though. He's usually up there in the favorite directors of the apparent demographics of this list.
The Dark Knight Rises is not just the worst movie on this list; it's one of the worst movies to ever make millions of dollars. Fight me IRL if you disagree
I don't think it's the worst movie on this list. Probably not even in the bottom 20. But there's at least a case that could be made for that. On the other hand, worst movie to make "millions" of dollars? Are you kidding? Ballistic: Ecks vs. Sever, currently sitting at 0% on the Tomatometer, made "millions" of dollars (14, to be exact). The worst movies ever made, if they get a wide release, will still earn at least two million dollars. Do you mean worst to make a billion dollars? But it's not even close to the worst in that category, either. Two Pirates movies, Jurassic World, Furious 7, Minions, two Transformers movies, and the last Harry Potter film all grossed over a billion dollars internationally.
Ecks vs. Sever was my least favorite movie experience of my life. Terrible films usually reach a point of badness at which it almost becomes charming, or you at least want to see how much it can get (I am reminded of Adam Sandler's output from about 2009-2013. There are so many face-palm moments that you end up being engaged. Ecks vs. Sever was just wholly unpleasant, like being stuck in a room with a rancid piece of meat that stinks. You just have to sit there and endure it, with no strong reaction of any kind. You just try not to think about it.
Hard to pick a favorite for me off of Nolan's resume. Everything he's done has been great. But if forced to I think my personal favorite is Memento and least favorite is probably either Tenet or The Dark Knight Rises.
One disadvantage of the autocomplete is that you may not realize that it has dropped down to the answer space and you'll keep typing. That can mess up your next answer and the one after that and so on until you realize that even though you're typing in correct answers, they're not registering. I missed a lot of them that I DID type in but they didn't pop up.
Several titles were tough to come up based on the actor given. My brain does not immediately go to "Shawshank" when someone mentions Morgan Freeman. My brain had to overcome a number of red herrings like that.
Pulp Fiction is slightly overrated but I'd still say it's definitely top 15 material. I have Star Wars original trilogy all in my top 10 but I feel way too biased with that
Reasonably astute comment except for your remark about Fight Club, which is an all around exceptional film. But one of the things about films like Fight Club, being so different and controversial, is most people fall into one of two extreme camps, either loving or hating the movie. To me, I think that a film of this nature can't even be considered great unless there are large numbers of people who passionately hate it. "meh" to me means something like indifference or "it was okay"... which I don't think I've ever heard anyone say about Fight Club.
Fight Club is a weird one. I remember thinking it was really good when I saw it in the theater, but the fan base around it has become so toxic that I can see why many people are put off these days.
I always love doing this quiz, but I wish there was a little more time. As it is, just reading and taking the bare minimum of time to think about my answer (or moving on to the next if I can't think of anything within a few seconds), I have never had the time to get to the last items on the list :-/
plz also accept the original Titles and not just the English ones (like Das leben der anderen instead of The lives of others or La vite e Bella instead of Life is Beautiful). Not everyone watches these classics in English
No movie that new should be added. People's overall opinions and ratings fluctuate quite a bit after it first comes out. Let's see if Infinity War is still up there in six months or a year.
I kinda agree with this, if a movie is still considered really good 5-10 years after it's made, that's a much better indication that it's well made. I imagine avatar would have been near the top of the list when it came out, but 10 years later it's not in the top 100.
I know its not correct but possibly 'untouchables' as a type in for 'intouchables'.. tried that about 10 times as I was sure it would be on there but kept thinking it was called 'untouchables'.
The Intouchables was the highest-grossing French-language film ever made (might still be?). It was remade into an American movie starring Bryan Cranston and Kevin Hart called The Upside, which was not generally as well-regarded.
It saddens me that Monty Python and the Holy Grail isn't on the list. I'd certainly put it above films like Inglourious Basterds. Then again, I also wouldn't put Stanley Kubrick's various "classics" on the list either, so I know my opinions are not often representative of the majority.
I was glad to see Leon:The Professional and City of God here(for what it's worth). Two movies I really liked. Was disappointed with myself for missing Once Upon A Time in America, Double Indemnity and Grave of the Fireflies. All really good movies that I saw a long time ago. I was surprised to see Princess Mononoke in here but not Howl's Moving Castle, Spirited Away, Kiki's Delivery Service, Nausicaa of the Valley of the Winds or Ponyo; all of which I thought were as good as or better than Princess Mononoke. And in a similar vein, how does Snatch make the list and not Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels?
Knowing the crowd that populates IMDB, I was shocked while solving that only two Tarantino films made the list...then I gave up and realized I missed both Django and Basterds. Inglourious Basterds is by far my favorite of his movies. I've watched it at least twice in the past month. Ashamed I missed it.
my god you've got awful... just terrible... taste in film. Who doesn't like The Shawshank Redemption? And I don't recall you ever mentioning a movie that you did like. You only gripe about films that other people like. What is your idea of a good movie? Empire by Andy Warhol? Plan 9 From Outer Space? The Twilight saga? Maybe you're a big fan of the Hallmark Channel? Why don't you say something positive for once and tell us what we're all missing out on?
IMDb was 4chan with a language filter so they wiped out the entire history of comments. Too bad, it was a treasure of help and information if you steered away from blockbuster b.s. movies. Just overzealous fanboys voting over and over for their nerd favorites. The Top 100 was always a joke, with message boards pushing to drive the newest comic book movie to #1 all time and then congratulating themselves on how great their newest treasure in their 14-year-old lives was. A month later, repeat with something else.
Missing are two films I consider to be in the all-time Top 10 (if you haven't seen them, it would be worth your while): "The Best Years Of Our Lives" and "The Treasure Of The Sierra Madre".
A lot of good movies on here (many of which are good but not *that* good), but I have to say that 2001: A Space Odyssey is still the single most boring film I have ever watched.
I really enjoyed the slow pace of the movie. I am often a bit annoyed by modern movies trying to pace and cut everfaster and pushing an idiotic amount of plot into a single movie. Seeing movies like 2001, Yeelen, Eraserhead, were they just pump the breaks and give you time to enjoy, becomes soothing in contrast.
I watched the 1964 dr strangelove a couple of weeks ago. I had to force myself to watch to the end ( and if I wasn't very ill I probably wouldn't have. Would ve gotten up and done something else) I was curious what it was all about. But seriously really don't think I have ever seen anything more boring. And when it was done I was like, ok, that was.... an experience... I can atleast say I ve seen it now.. BUt sort of with the feeling of being abandoned at the busstop, confused and, ok now what?
Twelve minutes is not a lot to guess a hundred answers. Just over seven seconds to read each clue, think and type an answer. It probably needs closer to twenty mins, especially for those of us on Ipads who have to scroll down every time.
Imagine unironically placing Return of the Jedi -- the Star Wars movie that everyone considers the worst of the original trilogy and the one everyone agrees is the moment when Lucas cashed out to sell toys over making a good story -- above Citizen Kane, the movie that tops basically every "Best Movies of All Time" lists. IMDB users are strange.
this is such a straight, white man list lol but it is interesting to think how the list would change if it could be filtered to "top rated films by women" or LGBT people etc
No people were excluded everybody is allowed to rate those movies.
But yea if you are gonna target specific demographics (instead of allowing everyone to rate) like 6 year old kids you would get a different list than 80 year old grandmothers.
Well there is a bit of an issue there, given I doubt children are well-represented on IMDB. Plus I imagine the demographics of IMDB are skewed towards Americans, and they have to be computer users, so that likely excludes certain age groups etc.
Most of this list is movies by, for, and about white American men. Even with the historical constraints on who gets to make movies and the kind of audiences most are made for, there's a whole world of excellent movies that aren't included here -- likely because they're considered chick flicks or are otherwise aimed at a demographic less represented by IMDB raters.
I get that theres some really stupid inclusions (Irishman) and some pretty glaring exclusions (Taxi Driver, Robert de Niro has a lot I guess), but overall this list isn't too bad. You disliking means you generally disagree with the tastes of the general population
how do you explain once upon a time in america? a movie in which most people have never heard of..i got it right mainly because i worked at a video store around the time when it was released on video
There is never going to be a method in which the rating system is unbiased, because rating movies is subjective. I find that this public voting system is the best method of rating movies, and is more accurate than other metrics like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic. I also find it more accurate than individual reviews, because it accounts for the aggregate rating. The only clear disadvantage (outside of the sample size of 20,000 reviews) is the notable lack of Horror and Comedy movies, largely because there will be hordes of people who rate a movie on how scary/funny they think the movie is, rather than rating it based solely on the quality of the movie.
It depends what type of movie SHOULD be rewarded, shouldn't it? Do we want popcorn movies? Unartistic movies are beginning to garner more and more acclaim on things like IMDB, and I feel like that is directly related to how much effort the studios puts into manipulating those metrics. Personally, I usually find Meta Critic is a better indicator of the actual quality of the film whereas Rotten Tomatoes and IMDB seem to be manipulated by large studios. The popular vote, aside from manipulation, is flawed, too. I think almost anyone can agree that The Matrix is just NOT the 15th best movie of all time (circa 2021). It's an influential popcorn flick that's part of American culture... but it's not a masterpiece. Anyway, that is to say that IMDB seems to have shifted to a measure of just what gives people pleasure, rather than what they think has artistic merit. Transformers has a 7/10 on IDMB as of 2021... so... yeah. IMDB sucks.
Honestly from what I've seen IMDB tends to have more reasonable ratings than Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic, which will often be very skewed to one side, like tons of films will have 99% and then some have 5%
As a rabid hater yourself, are you mad that the people who have enjoyed these films outnumber you? I mean, pretty much every one of these movies were fantastic by almost any standard.
I actually think that, by and large, what happens on IMDb is the opposite of what you describe. In general, most of the ratings are absolutely spot-on. This is product of the "wisdom of crowds": the tendency to arrive at very close to the exact right answer when you average guesses from a very large number of people. But, sometimes, a film's large number of rabid haters (Titanic, Avatar), will bring down the average score much lower than it objectively ought to be. So it seems to me that the haters have more influence on IMDb than the fanboys do. Otherwise you might expect to see films like Twilight or Harry Potter or the Star Wars prequels near the top.
You also completely contradicted what you said above one year ago about us not being able to trust the ratings because most people would rate any film as average...
Could it be you haven't really thought through this analysis and are just leaving unbalanced knee-jerk comments? Because you saw some movies on the list that you didn't personally care for? hm....
Disproportionate to what? They make tons of superhero movies these days. If anything they're extremely underrepresented on the above list. Maybe you're just not aware that some of them are actually very good.
There are six comic book movies on this list. 6 out of 100. Or 6%.
In 2021, outside of China, 5 out of 10 of the 10 highest-grossing films worldwide were comic book movies. Or 50%. Only one of which was anywhere near good enough to make it on the above prestigious list... but it still fell just short.
They're extremely underrepresented. Also, the comic book movies that appear on the above list were, in addition to being rated very highly by thousands if not millions of IMDb user, also glowingly reviewed by film critics of all ages and genders. And every one of the 6 were thoroughly enjoyed by the 70-year-old grandmother that I often go to movies with (my mom). I know it hurts, but maybe try to open your mind just a little bit.
riight... all the teen boys out there just LOVE the Shawshank Redemption, The Godfather, and 12 Angry Men. Contemplative and deliberate black & white courtroom dramas are just a cynical ploy to sell toys and lunch boxes.
Some I think are good but overrated: The usual suspects, American history X, Whiplash, The pianist, The prestige, Requiem for a Dream, Eternal sunshine and Amadeus.
2) putting 'tom hanks' for 'toy story iii' is misleading!
3) i believe 'Nuovo Cinema Paradiso' should be accepted for 'Cinema Paradiso'
Cool quiz!
great quizz, but for typing 100 titles, 12 minutes is not enough! got only 42...
It's a shame that none of films by Andrzej Wajda, Pedro Almodóvar, Kim Ki-Duk, Terry Gilliam or Wong-Kar Wai - just to name a few - make the list. Jean-Pierre Jeunet does, but honestly, I'd choose Delicatessen over Amélie any day.
Some of my all-time favourite movies that I would include here are: The Big Lebowski, The Crow, Lady Vengeance, Birdcage Inn and Lady Snowblood.
Also, just in case anyone is taking recs from the comment section, I'd strongly recommend City of God. That's a great movie.
Those that shouldn't be in this list:
Pulp Fiction - nothing special.
All LOTR should be in top 10.
Fight Club - meh.
All 3 original SW in top 10
12 Angy men... watched for first time in last 5 years and its really hard to see people act like they used to - over exasperated.
The Professional? Didn't get the attraction.
T2 - top 20 easily.
oldboy? mmm no.
braveheart - easily top 20
Lots of others that are far over celebrated or simply missing.
Where's Predator? Groundhog Day? Shrek?
Twelve minutes is not a lot to guess a hundred answers. Just over seven seconds to read each clue, think and type an answer. It probably needs closer to twenty mins, especially for those of us on Ipads who have to scroll down every time.
But yea if you are gonna target specific demographics (instead of allowing everyone to rate) like 6 year old kids you would get a different list than 80 year old grandmothers.
(Though they both might like "UP" ;) )
That's what you get when it's open public voting. Completely unbalanced, knee-jerk assessment.
I actually think that, by and large, what happens on IMDb is the opposite of what you describe. In general, most of the ratings are absolutely spot-on. This is product of the "wisdom of crowds": the tendency to arrive at very close to the exact right answer when you average guesses from a very large number of people. But, sometimes, a film's large number of rabid haters (Titanic, Avatar), will bring down the average score much lower than it objectively ought to be. So it seems to me that the haters have more influence on IMDb than the fanboys do. Otherwise you might expect to see films like Twilight or Harry Potter or the Star Wars prequels near the top.
Could it be you haven't really thought through this analysis and are just leaving unbalanced knee-jerk comments? Because you saw some movies on the list that you didn't personally care for? hm....
In 2021, outside of China, 5 out of 10 of the 10 highest-grossing films worldwide were comic book movies. Or 50%. Only one of which was anywhere near good enough to make it on the above prestigious list... but it still fell just short.
They're extremely underrepresented. Also, the comic book movies that appear on the above list were, in addition to being rated very highly by thousands if not millions of IMDb user, also glowingly reviewed by film critics of all ages and genders. And every one of the 6 were thoroughly enjoyed by the 70-year-old grandmother that I often go to movies with (my mom). I know it hurts, but maybe try to open your mind just a little bit.
I'm guessing that you are a) not Indian, and b) haven't visited the cinema since 1939.
If the latter guess is accurate, you should go again! Things have gotten a lot better since then!
You effed up, IMDB