What about the Balrog? Seems to me like it was on screen more than 4 minutes between the fight in Moria, the flashbacks, and Gandalf's story in Two Towers.
I'm not so sure. I haven't measured it, but I feel like all of the balrog's actual appearances on screen were pretty short (like, <10 seconds), and I doubt they added up to 4 minutes total.
Can you accept the Steward of Gondor for Denthor? I appreciate it's his title rather than his given name, but surely it's close enough to be acceptable?
Except no one is referred to as “King of Gondor” (bar possibly Aragorn at the very very end)whereas Denethor is also called “The Steward of Gondor” fairly often.
The Lord of the Rings franchise spans around 11 hours of screen time. That is 660 minutes. How in the world could Aragorn only be in an hour and fifteen minutes of that time? The same goes for the rest of the Fellowship excluding Boromir.
Forgot Gamling and Grima. Gamling seemed to not have as much importance in the movie, same with Wormtongue which is the main reason I forgot them. Good quiz!
I thought the extended editions only added his scene at the beginning of Return of the King, maybe 3 minutes of screen time. Pretty sure there was an extra 4 hours of Treebeard in them though...
He is definitely mentioned. Off the top of my head I can remember two times: first, when he (Gamling) dresses up King Theoden for battle at Helm's Deep, he (the King) asks him, "Who am I, Gamling?"
Second time, when the Rohirrim arrive to Minas Tirith: "Gamling, follow the King's banner down the center!"
No. When you name your child Robert or Benjamin this is not a made-up name. It's a common name that has been in use for centuries if not millennia. You might be naming them after a family member, or after someone famous, or you might be picking the name out of a book. In any of these cases, you are not inventing the name yourself. And unless you intentionally riff on the spelling, everyone will know from convention how to spell your kid's name.
Tolkien was inventing these names out of thin air most of the time. That's obviously very different. And few would be expected to know how to spell them.
Both Arwen and Eowyn have roots in Welsh and Old English. Not knowing how to spell these names is no more unfair that me not knowing how to spell Ahsan Akhlaaq or Nisreen because i don't speak Arabic.
What about the elf they encounter in Lothlorien, who then goes to the Battle of Helm's Deep to help them? Haldir? Lindir? I cannot recall his name, but he must have been on screen for longer than 4 minutes, unless I am totally out to lunch.
Wow, Sauruman was only on screen from 9 minutes. It speaks wonders to Christopher Lee's performance that it felt like he was on-screen far more. A real stand-out actor in a memorable role.
Second time, when the Rohirrim arrive to Minas Tirith: "Gamling, follow the King's banner down the center!"
Tolkien was inventing these names out of thin air most of the time. That's obviously very different. And few would be expected to know how to spell them.
The Balrog, Déagol, Gothmog, Lurtz, Haldir, Isildur, Madril, Celeborn, Háma, Rosie Cotton, King of the Dead.
I guess they don't count Shadowfax or Brego as characters.