thumbnail

MLB Baseball Hall of Fame by Team

For each selected team name any player in the Hall of Fame who was inducted with that team as their primary team.
Answer must correspond to the highlighted box
The Rays, Marlins, and Diamondbacks have no Hall of Famers
Players only. Not including managers, etc...
Quiz by Quizmaster
Rate:
Last updated: April 20, 2024
You have not attempted this quiz yet.
First submittedAugust 8, 2019
Times taken8,557
Average score74.1%
Rating4.05
4:00
Enter answer here
0
 / 27 guessed
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
Team
#
Answer
Angels
1
Nolan Ryan
Astros
2
Craig Biggio | Jeff Bagwell
Athletics
11
Dennis Eckersley | Rickey Henderson | Rollie Fingers | +8 others
Blue Jays
2
Roberto Alomar | Roy Halladay
Braves
16
Greg Maddux | Chipper Jones | Hank Aaron | +13 others
Brewers
2
Paul Molitor | Robin Yount
Cardinals
16
Bob Gibson | Ozzie Smith | Stan Musial | +13 others
Cubs
16
Ernie Banks | Hack Wilson | Ryne Sandberg | +13 others
Dodgers
14
Jackie Robinson | Pee Wee Reese | Sandy Koufax | +11 others
Giants
24
Christy Mathewson | Willie Mays | Willie McCovey | +21 others
Guardians / Indians
13
Bob Feller | Jim Thome | Nap Lajoie | +10 others
Mariners
3
Ken Griffey, Jr. | Randy Johnson | Edgar Martinez
Mets
2
Mike Piazza | Tom Seaver
Nationals / Expos
4
Andre Dawson | Gary Carter | Tim Raines | Vladimir Guerrero
Orioles
10
Frank Robinson | Jim Palmer | Cal Ripken | +7 others
Padres
2
Tony Gwynn | Trevor Hoffman
Phillies
11
Grover Alexander | Mike Schmidt | Steve Carlton | +8 others
Pirates
12
Honus Wagner | Roberto Clemente | Willie Stargell | +9 others
Rangers
2
Adrián Beltré | Iván Rodríguez
Red Sox
12
Carl Yastrzemski | Pedro Martinez | Ted Williams | +9 others
Reds
7
Barry Larkin | Joe Morgan | Johnny Bench | +4 others
Rockies
2
Todd Helton | Larry Walker
Royals
1
George Brett
Tigers
11
Al Kaline | Alan Trammell | Ty Cobb | +8 others
Twins / Senators
11
Kirby Puckett | Rod Carew | Joe Mauer | Walter Johnson | +7 others
White Sox
11
Frank Thomas | Harold Baines | Luis Aparicio | + 8 others
Yankees
21
Babe Ruth | Joe DiMaggio | Mickey Mantle | +18 others
23 Comments
+1
Level 89
Aug 11, 2019
Aside from the newer expansion teams without much history only the California Angels are missing. That's kind of embarrassing.
+2
Level ∞
Aug 16, 2019
Turns out this was my mistake. They actually have two: Nolan Ryan and Vladimir Guerrero.
+1
Level 48
Apr 20, 2024
Hi Vladimir Guerrero was not an Angel...he was an Expo...
+1
Level ∞
Apr 20, 2024
Just checked and you are right. I wonder how this happened. I blame Wikipedia.
+1
Level 85
Aug 11, 2019
Wikipedia: "Ryan was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1999, . . . the Hall of Fame recognizes the Los Angeles Angels as his primary team."
+2
Level ∞
Aug 11, 2019
Well darn. Very confusing since he wears a Rangers cap but you are correct.
+1
Level 83
Aug 15, 2019
Per baseballhall.org, two edits: add Vladimir Guerrero (Angels); move Dave Winfield (Padres) to the Yankees.
+1
Level ∞
Aug 16, 2019
Fixed, thanks!
+1
Level 68
Apr 22, 2024
This is actually wrong. Winfield is in the Hall of Fame as a Padre, not a Yankee.
+1
Level 69
Aug 17, 2019
Awesome quiz!
+1
Level 38
Sep 24, 2019
Dave Winfield entered the Hall of Fame as a member of the Padres. Otherwise, great quiz!
+1
Level ∞
Sep 24, 2019
https://baseballhall.org/hall-of-famers/winfield-dave
+2
Level 54
Sep 24, 2019
Randy Johnson was enshrined as a Diamondback
+1
Level ∞
Sep 24, 2019
https://baseballhall.org/hall-of-famers/johnson-randy
+2
Level 54
Oct 25, 2019
https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/mlb/2015/01/16/randy-johnson-hall-of-fame-cap-to-have-d-backs-logo/21864639/
+2
Level ∞
Oct 25, 2019
The cap logo can be different from their primary team. Does it make sense? No.

This quiz uses information directly from the baseball Hall of Fame website. If you believe there is a mistake in their website, please let them know!

+2
Level 83
Jan 22, 2020
Looking from the outside, all of this is quite ridiculous. Why do you even need to pick one team? Especially as some had great careers with 2 teams. Just list all he's played for and that's it.
+1
Level 68
Sep 24, 2019
Good quiz, a little on the easy side, maybe a minute less would make it more challenging.
+1
Level 64
Jan 24, 2023
First comment in 4 years wow

Add Scott Rolen

+1
Level 74
Feb 2, 2023
I scored 26/27, drew a blank with the Rangers. Thanks for the quiz!
+1
Level 45
Oct 2, 2023
I know it’s not the team he played for the most but Randy Johnson won 4 Cy Young Awards in a row for the Diamondbacks, he only won 1 for the Mariners. In his Hall of Fame plaque he has a Diamondbacks hat on. He should be included for the Diamondbacks, the Mariners would still have players that work for them.
+2
Level ∞
Jan 24, 2024
I agree, but the Hall of Fame does not!
+1
Level 63
Apr 18, 2024
So happy to be able to answer with my all-time favorite pro-athlete: Mariano Rivera.