Excuse my ignorance, but why are neither Superman nor Batman included? They even had a film about them vs each other in 2016. And surely they are Marvel, are they not?
Surely they are not. Superman and Batman are both from DC Comics, Marvel's biggest competitor. There are and have been many different comic book-producing studios in the United States but Marvel and DC are the two biggest.
Ouch, I ll admit I don't know for every character if they are DC or marvel, just the bigger names. But I do know there are strong feelings about it and that you shouldnt get them the wrong way around ! Say this at a comic-con and you ll be swarmed by hundreds of angry fans with foam swords..
(I am curious if people would get more mad over this or over people confusing star wars with star trek...)
Of course there’s some MCU movies that are pretty bland as well. But I don’t think any of them are as bad as Howard the Duck, Elektra, or any of the Fantastic Fours.
The first Donner Superman film and the first two Burton Batman films were pretty good. Weird Science, V for Vendetta, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Tales from the Crypt: Demon Knight, Sin City, The Road to Perdition, Mystery Men, Men in Black, The Mask, A History of Violence, Hellboy, Ghost World, The Crow, Constantine, 300, and American Splendour were all pre-MCU, as well. Some of those were okay and others were downright brilliant. It wasn't all Elektra and Catwoman.
and... I know I'm in the minority here, but I actually think Howard the Duck is underrated. If you don't take it seriously (and why would you?) it's actually pretty funny.
As for the MCU films I think it's really remarkable that they've made 21 movies now and stayed so consistent. None of them are downright terrible. Though, in my subjective opinion, Captain Marvel, Iron Man 3, and Thor the Dark World were all pretty bad. Avengers Age of Ultron could have been a lot better. and Black Panther is hands down the most overrated comic book movie in history - objectively very "meh"
I agree with you that most of those films are somewhat entertaining but I was referring to movies that most people would associate with Marvel (as in the Marvel logo is clearly shown somewhere on screen or in posters). Though I still stand by my opinion that nothing in the MCU is as bad as what came before it.
In that case "everything else that people 'associate with Marvel' that came before the MCU not including Spider-Man, X-Men, Blade, and Daredevil"... is not a very long list of movies. :P That's basically Howard the Duck and The Fantastic Four and then you're at the end of the list.
and there are also Marvel movies that came out after the start of the MCU that are pretty dang bad. Not just Thor the Dark World and Captain Marvel (which were worse than all those good movies I listed above) but also... Ghost Rider Spirit of Vengeance, Punisher War Zone, Amazing Spider-Man 2, and the latest Fantastic Four reboot, which were arguably worse than Daredevil or Blade.
Blade was the first time they made a successful comic book movie that was not about Batman or Superman. Most other attempts back then were pretty laughably bad including the 1990s versions of Punisher and Captain America. Blade was a little corny and pretty low-budget but it showed that a comic book film without a super-well-known marquis character, taken seriously, adapted faithfully, could be an entertaining film and box office success.
but then X-Men (2000) and Spider-Man (2002) were both way better and way more successful than Blade. After those films made so much money that's when we started heading toward the current state of Hollywood where most of the money movies make every year comes from comic book movies. And this is because those movies were so well done compared to anything that came before or around the same time.
The sequels X2 and Spider-Man 2 are, IMO, two of the best comic book movies ever made. But... there were also some stinkers from that era.
it is often said and may be true, though, that if not for Blade then X-Men and Spider-Man would never have been made as both had been in production limbo for years before the success of New Line's humble little vampire flick pushed Fox and Sony to finally finish their own Marvel-licensed movies.
The first 2 Fantastic Four movies (not the 2015 reboot) were not spectacular, but entertaining enough. The director's cut of Daredevil was also far better than the theatrical version, though still not amazing. However, the spinoff movie Elektra was one of the worst, most idiotic pieces of garbage that has ever been committed to film. But you'd have to wait until the Daredevil Netflix show for a truly good rendition of that character, and also to see the Elektra character with a quality script.
Men in Black is based on a Malibu/Marvel comic book. There were four movies in the franchise, three of which came out after 1998 (the cutoff for this quiz). Can you please add this?
I'm still curious about the exclusion of Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse and Big Hero 6, both of which are firmly Marvel properties without even the gray area of being under a different imprint or starting under a different publisher, and were both most definitely feature films. If the quiz is about live-action movies only, it should specify that. The New Mutants should also be included, at least as part of the X-Men franchise if not on its own.
Again, odd that this is coming to the front page now months before some of these films are even released, just like the other MCU quiz that did that...
I'd suggest the caveat: "Includes only live-action films with a wide theatrical release." That would disqualify both Big Hero 6 and the David Hasselhoff Nick Fury movie. Would still need to add New Mutants, though.
Assuming it is referring to the Eternals, they are not technically an alien race, as they are an evolutionary offshoot, albeit genetically engineered, of humans. They are no more alien than X-Men.
You should update for the second venom movie and also possibly run the quiz through till the end of 2022 as we also have a clear picture of the movies that are coming out in 2022
A couple of people have mentioned this, but the 2nd Venom movie comes out next month and so a change in latest year and from 1 to 2 movies would be appreciated.
Don't forget Venom: Let There Be Carnage, The Marvels (part of the Captain Marvel series sort of), Ant Man and the Wasp:Quantumania, Black Panther: Wakanda Forever, Guardians of the Galaxy vol. 3, and Doctor Strange: Multiverse of Madness. Most of these aren't released yet, but Venom 2 is.
I have now read the caveat and can safely say that my previous comment is somewhat useless, but Spider-Man: No Way Home or Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse isn't counted. My assumption for the Spider-Man movies that are counted are Spider-Man, Spider-Man 2, Spider-Man 3, The Amazing Spider-Man, The Amazing Spider-Man 2, Spider-Man Homecoming and Spider-Man Far From Home along with one of the above. Please add the other!
I would assume that QM wasn't personally aware that the New Mutants were their own team, and so chose to rope them in with the X-Men, except that if that were true then the number of X-Men films should be 8, not 7.
Venom: Let There Be Carnage still hasn't been updated despite the description stating it includes all movies pre 2022. This list could use an update anyway as it needs a new addition through the legend that is Morbius.
It would’ve been nice to see Howard the Duck on here. I know the film is from 1986, but it had a $36 million budget. I assume the 1998 cutoff is to prevent Marvel’s super-low budget movies made for copyright purposes from being counted (like the 1990 Captain America).
With the new update, I'll reiterate the request that either animated features be included, or that the title and/or instructions specify "live-action only." Without that caveat, it's unclear why Big Hero 6 should be excluded, or why the two Spider-Verse movies shouldn't count towards Spider-Man's total.
I think this should clarify that it is live action only. Big Hero 6 is not included and the animated Spiderman movies are not included in the film count.
I think it's fantastic that there are quizzes for kids on this site as well as quizzes for adults. Marvel Comics, Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, Disney princesses, and Star Wars all get a look-in.
Technically, Big Hero 6 is based on Marvel comicbooks, too. They first appeared in their own short-lived series in, fittingly, 1998, and their stories are set in the same shared universe as most other Marvel comicbook stories are.
You could combine Daredevil and Elektra. Also, there is Big Hero 6 which you forgot. And Man-Thing which was released in theaters for a short time in 2005. Then of course there movies are based on comics that are owned by Marvel such as the Kingsman/Argylle franchise, the Kick-*ss movies, Men in Black franchise etc.
Even with the update, still no Big Hero 6? Sure, it‘s part of the Disney animated canon, but it‘s still based on a Marvel comicbook property. The New Mutants are their own distinct team, too, by the way. (I really hope this comment doesn‘t come off as snobby or snotty, I‘m not itending for it to.)
Guess it's time for the yearly bafflement that this quiz doesn't simply add the caveat "live action only" if they're so set on not counting the Spider-Verse movies from Spider-Man's total and excluding Big Hero 6 entirely.
(I am curious if people would get more mad over this or over people confusing star wars with star trek...)
But yeah, aside from those everything else before the MCU was pretty crap.
and... I know I'm in the minority here, but I actually think Howard the Duck is underrated. If you don't take it seriously (and why would you?) it's actually pretty funny.
but then X-Men (2000) and Spider-Man (2002) were both way better and way more successful than Blade. After those films made so much money that's when we started heading toward the current state of Hollywood where most of the money movies make every year comes from comic book movies. And this is because those movies were so well done compared to anything that came before or around the same time.
The sequels X2 and Spider-Man 2 are, IMO, two of the best comic book movies ever made. But... there were also some stinkers from that era.
The New Mutants (2020)
Venom: Let There Be Carnage (2021)
Perhaps it's worth adding them to this quiz?