thumbnail

MLB All-Stars by Team

Name the player with the most All-Star selections for each Major League team.
Times selected, not games played
Through 2023
Quiz by Quizmaster
Rate:
Last updated: July 9, 2023
You have not attempted this quiz yet.
First submittedJuly 16, 2010
Times taken32,289
Average score48.7%
Rating4.10
5:00
Enter player here:
0
 / 39 guessed
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
Team
#
Years
Player
Braves
21
1955–1975
Hank Aaron
Cardinals
21
1943–1963
Stan Musial
Giants
20
1954–1972
Willie Mays
Orioles
19
1983–2001
Cal Ripken
Red Sox
18
1963–1983
Carl Yastrzemski
Yankees
16
1952–1968
Mickey Mantle
Padres
15
1984–1999
Tony Gwynn
Tigers
15
1955–1974
Al Kaline
Reds
14
1968–1983
Johnny Bench
Royals
13
1976–1988
George Brett
Phillies
12
1974–1989
Mike Schmidt
Pirates
12
1960–1972
Roberto Clemente
Twins
12
1967–1978
Rod Carew
White Sox
12
1951–1963
Nellie Fox
Angels
11
2012–2023
Mike Trout
Cubs
11
1955–1969
Ernie Banks
Dodgers
10
1942–1954
Pee Wee Reese
2011–2023
Clayton Kershaw
Mariners
10
2001–2010
Ichiro Suzuki
1990–1999
Ken Griffey, Jr.
Team
#
Years
Player
Rangers
10
1992–2001
Ivan Rodriguez
Athletics
9
1987–1997
Mark McGwire
Mets
9
1967–1977
Tom Seaver
Astros
8
2011–2022
José Altuve
Guardians/Indians
8
1938–1950
Bob Feller
1940–1948
Lou Boudreau
Blue Jays
7
1980–1990
Dave Stieb
Nationals/Expos
7
1975–1984
Gary Carter
1981–1987
Tim Raines
Diamondbacks
6
2013–2018
Paul Goldschmidt
Brewers
5
2008–2012
Ryan Braun
5
1979–1985
Cecil Cooper
5
1980–1992
Paul Molitor
Rockies
5
2000–2004
Todd Helton
2015–2019
Nolan Arenado
Marlins
4
2004–2007
Miguel Cabrera
4
2012–2017
Giancarlo Stanton
Rays
4
2004–2010
Carl Crawford
4
2010–2014
David Price
36 Comments
+1
Level 67
Jul 11, 2013
Funny to look at some of these teams like the Mets, Orioles, Padres, Royals that had one remarkable player make it so many times and absolutely no one else comes to mind (maybe Piazza for the Mets?). And others, you scroll through ten names in your head and just start guessing blindly. Cannot believe Robin Yount didn't make it for the Brewers, Pete Rose for the Reds, or Duke Snider for the Dodgers. Very interesting stuff.
+2
Level 43
Jul 11, 2013
More came to mind for each, though not many for the Royals - Hal McRae, Amos Otis. besides Piazza for the Mets - Gooden, Strawberry, Beltran, Wright and Carter. Orioles - Frank Robinson, Palmer, Brooks Robinson, Murray, Powell. Padres - Gonzalez, Hoffman, Nate Colbert, Winfield.

Rose didn't stay with the Reds long enough to surpass Bench. I was also surprised about Robin Yount.

+2
Level 76
Jan 31, 2016
Frank White, Willie Wilson, Dan Quisenberry (and a whole new generation now)
+1
Level 84
May 2, 2017
AUSCUBA: "Rose didn't stay with the Reds long enough to surpass Bench."

What? Bench was with the Reds for 16 full seasons. (1968-1983) Rose was with the Reds for 16 full seasons (1963-1978) to start his career. He came back for a half-season in 1984, and tacked on 2 more seasons after that.

+3
Level 64
Jul 11, 2017
We remember players from their prime periods. Players move so much today, these lists won't change much.

Yount was a total surprise. Played forever for one team and copped two MVPs.

F. Robinson moved around, but Brooks? Ripken really was an iron man, huh?

+1
Level 83
Jul 26, 2021
It's a shame Bo Jackson got hurt. He'd have racked up a dozen or more.
+2
Level 66
Jan 13, 2023
Yep, I was sure the Cecil Cooper space was Yount. Missed four, and Cooper was the only one of the four who retired after I was born.
+1
Level 68
Jul 17, 2013
Remember though, Rose played for two other teams.
+1
Level 54
Aug 16, 2013
fun quiz. 30/37. I think I could have squeezed out a couple more but time ran out.
+1
Level 43
Feb 25, 2016
Cool quiz
+3
Level 59
Jun 4, 2016
ALWAYS TODD HELTON! When will I learn. Capital of Burkina Faso.. Ouagadougo? NO TODD HELTON! :)
+1
Level 64
Jul 11, 2017
Yep, Helton is your default Rockie. So many players put up inflated numbers there, we remember them as Rockies. Burks, Galarraga, Walker and such were All Stars from other teams.
+1
Level 77
May 1, 2017
How can you be a 15 time all-star if you only played 13 seasons? At one time were there multiple all-star games in a season?
+2
Level 84
May 2, 2017
Yep. From 1959 thru 1962, there were 2 All-Star games played each season. So even though Roberto Clemente only had 12 All-Star seasons, he was a 15-time All-Star. (twice in 1960, twice in 1961 and twice in 1962)

He was not an All-Star in 1968, the only time after 1960 that he failed to hit .300.

+1
Level 67
Jul 11, 2017
Very interesting. Two all-star games in one season sounds preposterous, but then, the MLB thrives on oversaturation...
+1
Level 64
Jul 10, 2023
Stu Miller of the Giants finished both games in 1961. He got the win in game one at Candlestick (I was there) and game two at Fenway ended in a tie.
+1
Level 72
Apr 1, 2018
I don't agree with the Red Sox one, Ted Williams was 19x All-Star and I think it's due to the double All-Star Games of 1959 and 1960.
+1
Level 86
Jul 18, 2018
Baseball-Reference agrees. Williams made 19 All-Star games for the Sox, and Yaz made 18.
+1
Level ∞
Jul 1, 2019
Ted Williams played 19 all-star games but was selected only 17 times. In some years, there were two All-Star games.
+3
Level 59
Jul 10, 2018
Roberto Clemente should be Pirates, not Padres.
+1
Level 52
Jul 11, 2018
Agreed.
+1
Level ∞
Jul 11, 2018
Fixed
+1
Level 73
Sep 28, 2018
Great quiz, thank you. I enjoyed doing it. Most of them were easy but a few sleepers on the list too.
+1
Level 72
Oct 25, 2018
Mantle is listed with 16 appearances, but he had 20
+1
Level ∞
Oct 25, 2018
Selections not appearances. In some years, there were multiple All-Star games. Mantle didn't even play in 20 seasons.
+1
Level 14
Dec 15, 2020
can you do more football quizes please?
+1
Level 58
Jul 23, 2021
How can someone have fifteen All-Star seasons for a team if he was only there for thirteen years?
+1
Level ∞
Jul 24, 2021
Whoops. This has been fixed. Clemente played in 15 All-Star games, having been selected 12 times. There were some years that had multiple All-Star games.
+2
Level 63
Jul 23, 2021
Great quiz. Super surprised that neither Robin Yount nor Evan Longoria were #1 for their respective teams.
+7
Level 71
Jul 23, 2021
Never knew there was a player called Al Kaline. Must have been a pretty basic guy...
+3
Level 67
Jul 23, 2021
How have I never noticed this before?
+3
Level 89
Nov 3, 2021
What a caustic comment! ;)
+1
Level 83
Jul 19, 2022
Didn't pass the acid test though...
+1
Level 91
Jul 22, 2022
Comments like this are really corrosive to the Jetpunk community.
+1
Level 66
Jan 13, 2023
Appreciate you took the time to accept nicknames like "Goldy" and "Miggy"; tried them not really expecting either to work. "Gio" and "Giancarlo" were reaches, and I won't be that guy who asks you to add more. Well, this time, anyway.
+1
Level 78
Jul 10, 2023
I couldn't help but notice the use of former/current team names. Any reason why you didn't do the same for the Rays?