| Clue | Muppet | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| "It's not easy being green" | Kermit the Frog | 96%
|
| He wants cookie | Cookie Monster | 95%
|
| Porcine girlfriend of the above | Miss Piggy | 95%
|
| He's eight feet tall and yellow | Big Bird | 94%
|
| Red toddler muppet made into a popular doll | Elmo | 87%
|
| He takes baths with his rubber ducky | Ernie | 84%
|
| Numerical vampire | Count von Count | 83%
|
| "Evil" roommate of the above | Bert | 82%
|
| He lives in a trash can | Oscar the Grouch | 81%
|
| Bear who tells bad jokes and says "Wocka Wocka Wocka" | Fozzie Bear | 72%
|
| Crazed "Muppet Show" drummer | Animal | 71%
|
| Long-suffering assistant of the above | Beaker | 59%
|
| Mumbling cook | Swedish Chef | 58%
|
| "Great" stuntman | Gonzo the Great | 49%
|
| Blue "Sesame Street" monster who does not use contractions | Grover | 47%
|
| The other one | Waldorf | 33%
|
| Scientist whose experiments have unfortunate results | Dr. Bunsen Honeydew | 30%
|
| One of the elderly "Muppet Show" hecklers | Statler | 30%
|