Got to be way more than 11. Luck, Newton, Stafford, Ryan, Flacco, Cutler, Smith, Rodgers, Manning, Rivers, Big Ben, Palmer, Vick and Pennington. That's being strict, who do you leave out?
Purely subjectively, I'd take Cutler, Smith, and Pennington off that list. It really depends on your definition of "any good". If all you're shooting for is winning 60% of your games and maybe a first round playoff loss, maybe you could expand the list a bit.
Pennington was very good. He was mostly ignored in the press because he had no flash, no personality, and he was on bad Jets teams for most of his career, but he had a few really big years (Comeback Player of the Year with the Dolphins, 13-3 with the Jets, among others) and was never a liability. He is second all-time in completion percentage, behind only Drew Brees. Granted, that doesn't make him a superstar because he mostly played the short yardage game. But still, a QB who plays ten years and has a higher completion percentage than all but one other player (who is himself one of the best QB's ever) has to at least qualify as "good."
The Browns, Bears, Bills, Redskins, Titans, Raiders Jaguars and Broncos have drafted most of these guys, the other 24 teams seem to appear here only once or twice. And most of the picks those repeat #1 draft teams made are the busts, and only the Broncos have a recent history of winning out of that group. And the Broncos' victorious seasons were with a QB they picked up from someone else when he was too beat up for the Colts to keep him, not with one of the 6 guys they drafted. Just goes to prove that how you manage a team makes a difference. The draft does matter.
The Colts did not part with Peyton Manning simply because he was "beat up". They had a chance to draft their next franchise QB in Andrew Luck, and there wasn't going to be room for both of them on the same roster. (to say nothing about the salary cap implications) Indy did the only sensible thing, IMO, and parted amicably with Peyton. I'm sure it did not come as a surprise to him.
I can't believe I got them all (2:08). It just shows you how critical a first round quarterback is to a franchise's fortunes, either good or bad.
The good ones are mostly all still playing and the bad ones you still remember because of how far back they set their franchise.
There were a few that were more anonymous because their teams moved on quicker or they were late-first-round guys who weren't highly touted, but it's amazing how relevant a lot of these names/picks still are to franchise fortunes today.
Four of these guys have played for the Vikings. Arguably the best was Bradford, who just couldn't stay healthy. Bridgewater was pretty promising until the day his knee exploded out of nowhere in practice (supposedly the injury was so bad that some of his teammates were physically ill from having seen it). Ponder, while not as big a bust as some of the folks on this list, definitely wasn't worth a first-round pick. Josh Freeman only played in one game, but it was a memorable one: he completed 37.7% of his passes and left people wondering what in the world the coaching staff was smoking putting him in there.
Who played QB for the Vikings against the Giants on Monday Night Football in 2013 or 2014? It was the worst football game I've ever seen. The Vikings' QB either got hurt or was benched, and then they brought in someone who had maybe the worst QB performance I've ever seen. Might have been Joe Webb. I can't remember for certain. But the whole game was unwatchable. Eli Manning stunk too. It got so bad that Mike Tirico became openly hostile on the microphone.
The Browns had Weeden (dumb), Campbell (wasn't horrible), Quinn (not good), Manziel (really dumb), Mayfield (good), and Watson (not worth what was given up for him).
The Falcons had Vick (good but dumb choices off the field), Ryan (best QB in franchise history), Mariota (weird choice), and now Penix.
In the end, Luck (drafted to replace Manning) only lasted 2 seasons longer than Manning.
The Colts could have just kept Manning, who went on to set multiple single-season passing records during his years with the Broncos.
The good ones are mostly all still playing and the bad ones you still remember because of how far back they set their franchise.
There were a few that were more anonymous because their teams moved on quicker or they were late-first-round guys who weren't highly touted, but it's amazing how relevant a lot of these names/picks still are to franchise fortunes today.
The Browns had Weeden (dumb), Campbell (wasn't horrible), Quinn (not good), Manziel (really dumb), Mayfield (good), and Watson (not worth what was given up for him).
The Falcons had Vick (good but dumb choices off the field), Ryan (best QB in franchise history), Mariota (weird choice), and now Penix.