Exactly. He's a football player first and foremost. Would've been any other murder case without that. I started thinking along the line of DB Cooper seeing criminal.
The murders are not debatable. "Acquitted" does not mean "innocent." It means only that the 12 specific people on the jury did not think there was enough to evidence to be certain beyond any reasonable doubt that he was guilty. The only thing their judgment binds is the government's ability to sentence Simpson for that crime. No one else is bound in any way to abide by their judgment. The rest of us are free to use our common sense and the information available to draw our own conclusions. OJ absolutely murdered Nicole Brown and Ronald Goldman. The fact that 12 random people couldn't be sure of that after a circus trial filled with obfuscation and all manner of other absurdity doesn't change reality. He did it.
I think that whilst criminal is accurate for OJ Simpson, it wasn't a very helpful clue. Phil Spector also ended his career by murdering someone, but he would definitely be listed as 'Musician/Producer' and not 'criminal'.
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/S/SimpO.00.htm
Seymour Skinner - The Simpsons [S04E16]
Great quiz.