There's an El Dorado in Arkansas (pronounced el door-AYE-doe), but I figured the quiz was alluding to the lost city of gold, so correctly guessed "fictional".
I visited the town before I ever heard of the book! It is the first place in northwest Yunnan Province coming from the south where the majority of the residents are ethnically Tibetan. It sits at over 10,000' in elevation and provides quite a cultural experience worth checking out if you ever find yourself in the area.
South Park is a real place, and predates the show. It's the name of a basin in Park County, Colorado. The name of the biggest town in that basin is Fairplay. Trey Parker grew up 40 miles away in Conifer (also referenced on the show). The name of the fictionalized town in the show is the same as the basin: South Park. So... if you wanted to make this clearly a fictional place you'd have to specify "the town of South Park, CO."
Also maybe better for the real place clues to use The Bermuda Triangle, which is also real but has more legendary tales associated with it? I don't think many people doubt the existence of Bermuda.
And Xanadu is a little iffy. Sort of like Atlantis. Based on a real place - Shangdu - as visited by Marco Polo. But heavily mythologized as Xanadu, in popular consciousness, after appearing in a poem by Samuel Coleridge. Kind of like Plato's writings about Atlantis. Only difference being that we don't know for certain where the real place was that the legends of Atlantis sprung from, or if there truly was one. But it's not unlikely.
Historians used to think that Troy was a made-up place, too.
Nitpicking, perhaps, but while Mount Zion is adjacent to but outside the 16th century Ottoman wall, it is very much in the center of the city of Jerusalem
Yes, I believe that's exactly what they mean. They're saying that Atlantis is like Troy, in that they were/are both assumed to be myths, but that unlike Troy it just hasn't been found yet.
I believe Plato said it was a real place, and I'll believe that over these archeologists who keep "discovering" that humanity is older than expected. They only believe what they see and find, which is silly to me. As mentioned, Troy was not considered real until it was discovered to be so.
It's almost like people change their mind once there's evidence, instead of just blindly believing whatever they feel is real, or would like to be real.
to say definitely that Atlantis is fictional is quite odd. there's quite a bit of evidence to suggest the opposite. the most impressive of which is Edgar Cayce's various assertions on it, including the existence of a hidden chamber of their records under a paw of the Sphinx, proven in 2005 that it is in fact there, but the Egyptian government refuses to allow it to be explored. either way, the book is most definitely not closed.
Quite surprised, and gratified, to have made 100% on this quiz....common sense folks! Not talking about obscure places named for famous fictional and/or nonfictional locales, but their place in literature and mythology....Thanks for a very interesting quiz.
Richat structure in Mauritania is the most likely location of Atlantis as described by Plato. When the sea levels was higher and the Sahara was yet to exist, this area would have been on an island.
Atlantis being fictional or real is still disputed, as there isn't enough evidence to prove or disprove it.
The Richat structure is a geological formation that's pretty easy to explain. The Earth's crust developed a bump, pushing the various rock layers up towards the middle. Then the bump got eroded, or essentially scraped away, leaving behind a bunch of flat concentric rings.
The Richat structure is nowhere near the reported location of Atlantis, it's orders of magnitude larger than the reported size of Atlantis, and nothing of note has ever been found there.
Atlantis is totally real though. Just not in the Sahara.
And there are no doubt many strip clubs named Valhalla. The fact remains that Shangri-La was originally invented as a work of fiction. Any real city came later.
Perhaps take Valhalla out - the vikings believed it a real place, and the alternative today is Christianity's heaven or Islam's Jannah - I'm sure many vikings would be turning in their treasure-filled Earth-mound and the one's still alive groaning in the pain of grief and sorrow.
I'm dumb. Of course Loch Ness is real and I knew it was real, but I was so accustomed to denying the existence of the Loch Ness Monster that I said it wasn't. Whoops.
I would argue that fiction and mythology/religion are not necessarily the same thing. Wakanda is fictional. There is no real place with that name and there are no people or cultures that believe in its existence. Valhalla had, and perhaps has, a very real group of people who wholeheartedly believe that it is an actual place.
Greetings from HEL
Great Quiz! I can hit myself for missing Loch Ness (I was thinking of the monster of course! 👾)! The lake itself is quite real indeed! LOL!
Real:
-Zanzibar
-Luxor
-Limpopo River
-Mt Olympus
-Lindisfarne
-Xanadu
-Bermuda
-Outer Mongolia
-Lake Placid
Fictional:
-Isle of Lucy
-Skull Island
-Dawson's Creek
-Lilliput
-Ambridge (for the UK listeners!)
-South Park
-Middlemarch
-Los Santos/Liberty City
Also maybe better for the real place clues to use The Bermuda Triangle, which is also real but has more legendary tales associated with it? I don't think many people doubt the existence of Bermuda.
Historians used to think that Troy was a made-up place, too.
Would be cool if you could adjust that question!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantis
For one, Atlantis of legend wasn't anywhere near Egypt, but out in the Atlantic Ocean.
Love Alex Thirkell's ideas!
Atlantis being fictional or real is still disputed, as there isn't enough evidence to prove or disprove it.
The Richat structure is nowhere near the reported location of Atlantis, it's orders of magnitude larger than the reported size of Atlantis, and nothing of note has ever been found there.
Atlantis is totally real though. Just not in the Sahara.
Valhalla (Wikipedia)
Valhalla (Wikipedia)
first try
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shangri-La_City