That's an insipid BSAB argument. The whole point of the song is that no person is being worshiped. And most American presidents aren't born into a life of obscene opulence (relative to America, at least). Obama was from a single-parent family, Clinton grew up poor, many others were born poor or middle class.
"God Save Our King" has nothing to do with anyone born in a log cabin.
Our version, "America", a.k.a. "My Country 'Tis Of Thee" is neutral on socioeconomic status other than a passing mention of Pilgrims who were dirt floor poor.
The American version appeals to the nation itself, not an individual demigod.
I'm an Aussie and got 4/16, but I did get perilous, the least gotten, so I'm happy with myself. Although I didn't get star-spangled, so maybe I shouldn't be so happy...
As an American, I think our national anthem stinks. God Bless America would be a far better choice, or Battle Cry of Freedom even. Not only is the Star Spangled Banner (only the first verse of which is considered the national anthem it seems) it was written by Francis Scott Key about one of our most forgotten wars: the War of 1812...one that was a stalemate for us at BEST. God Bless America is not about war and death at all, BUT if war must be the choice, why not one from the Revolution, or from the Civil War?
I also think 'O Canada', and the former USSR anthem have always been great tunes.
I think the Star-Spangled Banner is much better. It gets unfairly maligned by people who don't even understand what it's about. America the Beautiful is kind of generic, and also overly religious, plus nobody actually knows any of it beyond the first verse.
The Star-Spangled Banner relates to a real event in history, and is about resilience and fortitude in the face of tyranny during an attack on the country.
I know more verses of America the Beautiful than I know extra verses of our anthem. I like both of them, but there's something heart-stirring about the music of the national anthem for me that isn't there with AtB. Thanks for letting us borrow your drinking song, Brits!
I'm with you. Especially if one reads beyond the first verse. The Star Spangled Banner gets increasingly vengeful and bitter, while AtB uses each verse to describe one of the unique successes of the US, and then express hope that we can build from a small success to a larger. As much as I love the story of the writing of the Star Spangled Banner (old guy left alone by invading British troops on his word he will not cause trouble becomes incensed when he sees the light from the flames in Washington, D.C., so takes three British soldiers prisoner, captured in turn when the main troops return, then the lawyer negotiating his release on board a British ship must watch the bombardment of Fort McHenry from that same ship, fearing the fort would be taken and his new country conquered...and as the light rises, the flag waves above the fort!), the sentiment expressed by Katherine Lee Bates in AtB — that America be not only a great country, but a good one. Such a better aspiration!
I think you'd be surprised how weirdly bitter a lot of them are. I believe its the Italian anthem that specifically insults Austria multiple times. While I love AtB, I think that Star Spangled Banner's story is what puts it well above in terms of being the national anthem. Also, everyone who complains about it being hard to sing, I think makes it a better song to actually listen to and more fun at public events. It's not like anyone is required to hit the high note or anything.
Woah, woah, woah. As a Marylander who grew up twenty minutes from Baltimore, I assure you the Star-Spangled Banner is amazing. It's not about winning a war, it's about fortitude and hope. Francis Scott Key was stuck on a boat as a prisoner and the joy of seeing Baltimore wave the American flag after a night-long battle gave him so much joy and hope for the future that he wrote a poem commemorating it. (and it was a poem at first, only set to music later, so don't blame him for the tune itself!) I feel like that's better than "we are fighting against ourselves in a war and so many people are dead oh my god"
I kinda like the tune of the Star-Spangled Banner (at least when it's not sung with soome ridiculous over-exagerated vibrato like it sometimes is at games), but I find the lyrics to be pretty poor from a poetic standpoint, and the meaning rather weak. Of course, that's the case for many anthems around the world. One of my favourite tunes is "Flower of Scotland", and lyrically, I really like "Auferstanden aus Ruinen", which was the anthem of East Germany (it's not always the best states that have the best anthems). I also like the South African anthem - not that it's particularly well-written and beautiful, but I like how confusing it is (five languages, two different tunes).
That above was supposed to read: "The Star Spangled Banner was written....the "Not only..." and "It was," were supposed to be edited out...sorry about that.
the real test would be the second and third verses. To the anthem haters, you need to review the bombing of Fort McHenry and the story behind that. It's our anthem so that we remember those people who held up the staff with their dead bodies. Yes it was a stalemate, but that is the point. We stood up to the best in the world at the time, again, and we didn't fall.
How about the FOURTH verse? For some reason I'll never fully understand, my high school made us recite that (not sing, recite) that every morning after the Pledge, so I've still got that one down.
Yes, Key was a slave owner at the time he wrote the song, and that verse was to address escaped slaves who had been recruited by the British to fight against the Americans. Key later became anti-slavery and fought to end it, and he also served as a lawyer for slaves fighting for their freedom. Our history cannot change, but thankfully the hearts of men can.
That's almost certainly not the meaning of the line that mentions "slave". It's more likely a reference to the British as subjects of a king ("slaves") while Americans are citizens of the "home of the free". There's no good reason except modern politics to take a literal reading there.
I'm a New Zealander and I got 100% on this quiz. I have friends from my stay in America that would not get any. :( It's sad but then again I know Kiwi's who don't know the NZ national anthem, or they only know it in English and not Maori.
I like national anthems in general, and I've learned a few of them, including the NZ one! I find the Maori part, which of course I don't understand, very beautiful. I'm not a fan of the English part, though. Too religious and too British-colonial for me!
The only reason I didn't finish earlier is because I was singing the song as I typed the answers.......I'm American (my elementary school played this song every day of every school year-I'm not likely to forget it) so I got a perfect.
I'm Canadian and I think it's a great anthem! Actually, I love all the U.S. patriotic songs. This Land Is Your Land; God Bless America; My Country Tis of Thee (although the melody is stolen--uh, borrowed LOL--from the British national anthem)--they're all great to sing.
The original poem was very heartfelt and emotional. During the War of 1812 the British had already burned our capital, and many feared our young country was in danger of losing our independence only a few years after winning it. Francis Scott Key was being held on a ship while the British were firing on Ft. McHenry near Baltimore. He watched and listened to the bombs and rockets bombarding the fort all night and couldn't imagine that the fort could withstand all the shelling. When the sun rose and he saw that the US flag was still flying over the fort rather than the British one, he was moved to write the poem, "In Defence of Ft. M'Henry". It became a symbol of perseverance and hope for our new nation. (I do find it ironic that Key wrote the poem while thinking of the tune of an old but popular British drinking song, "The Anacreontic Song" and that became the melody when the poem was set to music.)
He used the "rocket's red glare and the bombs bursting in air" to see that the flag was still standing over Ft. McHenry. That was because the British had his friend captive and made a deal that if by morning the American flag hadn't fallen they would give him back. I'm pretty sure that's part of the story correct me if I'm wrong
every American should know the words to this song like the back of their hand. I can't believe how many joke about not knowing it. People died so you could have the freedom of living here. Don't they teach this in schools anymore?
Knowing the lyrics to a song is much less important than living by values that honor what people died for. Being a good American does not mean eating apple pie, loving baseball, and knowing the words to this song. People need to stop insisting that it does.
I'd rather 3,000,000 Americans that don't know the words but treat people with respect than 3,000,000 who can sing every note but treat people badly.
Hating politicians who abuse patriotism in the quest for power and m oney is not the same as hating the country. Nor is hating the things they do. Hating what your country has become in the eyes of the world is not the same as hating the country either. We all wonder why Germans did not stand up to Hitler, but then refuse to stand up to Bush/Cheney as they marched into a country that did not attack us, and gave speeches threatening others who did not behave as they wanted them to. Sometimes the most patriotism is shown by those demanding the best from their country instead of ignoring the worst. Of course those who abuse our power are going to namecall and pretend those who are critical "hate" the country--it's the only thing they have. Wake up. Don't repeat such bs. Americans don't love the country less just because they demand it to be its best--any more than a parent hates a child when they demand it live up to its potential.
Many Americans do not hate their own country. Where are you getting that from? It is a core American value to challenge our government. So yeah, we hate Congress. A lot. But your government is not your country.
Many Americans do actually hate their country. I know several. Mostly Chomsky acolytes. Though there are some far right nuts who do, as well. I don't find the concept in itself sad, as no country really deserves to be loved or hated. Patriotism, and indeed nationalism, are ideas that ought to be retired from human consciousness. So to me the fact that they hate the US isn't as sad as the fact that, most of the time, the reason they hate the USA is that they believe some other country is better. All things of course being relative, it's very rare that I meet anyone who hates the USA for valid reasons.
It's appalling that there's only one word that had 100%. I didn't think it would be that low... I guess more Americans are taking this quiz than I thought.
I am a war fanatic. Speaking of the Civil War, I've been to an actual battlefield. It is the one in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. My family owns an M1 Garand used in Vietnam. I own a pellet gun which is an impersonation of a Winchester 77
Being from Denmark it is weird that I could do this in my sleep. And the same goes for the national anthems of Germany, France, Italy, United Kingdom and Brazil. And Denmark obviously.
It shocks me how many Americans don't know the lyrics to the national anthem. Missing one word is fine, but not knowing a whole line just seems crazy to me. You hear it so much growing up, it would be like not knowing the lyrics to Twinkle Twinkle. Granted there are some big words in there, come on.
There are non-American People on this site you know. From the comments you can tell that a few non-Americans are trying this. I didn't know the whole thing but got 53% and that's okay. I don't watch sports and got the answers I knew from watching Youtube videos of famous people singing it. Would you get 53% of a foreign anthem?
I wouldn't, but I would like to try if people want to post versions of their own anthems. (I think I've seen similar versions for Canada and Australia.) I could get a few words from the anthems of Canada, UK, and maybe Germany and Australia, but probably not other countries except common words.
You can't get an answer partially right. What are you talking about? Does it say in the stats you got that answer right 50% of the time? You probably took the quiz before and forgot.
As a European I know the story behind the poem and Francis Scott Key but I can only remember parts of the song and the rest gets mixed up with Oh Canada. :D
Another quiz where I would love to see the split in scores between American takers and non American, or even non North American's, just to see what the drop off is like.
I'm from Canada and got a 98%...if it wasn't for the "O'er" i would have had 100%. I tried again and again to get that...knew what i wanted to put, but couldn't get the spelling....lol
Got every single word and I'm not even American.^^ Still I've heard the anthem often enough to know the words and every time I hear it I'm tempted to sing along...
I stopped when the very first word is misspelled so I was left with Osaycanyouseebythedawnsearlylight on the answer box because it never cleared when I filled in the first word correctly. "Oh" is not the early 19th Century poetic spelling.
I thought it couldn’t get worse that Carl Lewis’s legendary “Francis Scott off-Key” performance before the Nets game, but I do think he knew the words.
I guess I've seen too many NHL hockey games. This Canadian got 100%. Be sure to watch the YouTube video where the mic goes out at a Maple Leafs game and the crowd finishes the Star Spangled Banner for the singer. Cool!
My favorite was I think the 2006 Stanley Cup Finals in Edmonton after some Americans had made negative comments about the Canadian anthem played before the games in the US. The Edmonton crowd took over from the singer entirely; it was excellent.
It’s 2023 and I still dislike having the Star Spangled Banner be the American national anthem. Hail Columbia (currently the Vice President’s official theme) would be a far better choice.
(Okay, fine I'm Canadian, close enough)
Our version, "America", a.k.a. "My Country 'Tis Of Thee" is neutral on socioeconomic status other than a passing mention of Pilgrims who were dirt floor poor.
The American version appeals to the nation itself, not an individual demigod.
I also think 'O Canada', and the former USSR anthem have always been great tunes.
The Star-Spangled Banner relates to a real event in history, and is about resilience and fortitude in the face of tyranny during an attack on the country.
It's a stupid song anyway.
(A show in which people get drunk and tell historical stories. It is infinitely amusing, and surprisingly informative.)
I did the whole thing 100% correctly and had 2 minutes left.
I'd rather 3,000,000 Americans that don't know the words but treat people with respect than 3,000,000 who can sing every note but treat people badly.
As it should be.
I typed "broad" for "broad stripes" and then sat there. I hit enter, and it said it was not correct.
My confusion was great. It was greater when it wouldn't accept "red."
Once I figured out I was supposed to type two words, I was fine, but that is still kind of a bug...
I only missed one (broad) and that's probably because I misspelled it.
Should be CHIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEFS!!!
what the anthem was depicting? Awesome tribute to our soldiers (of
all eras)!
Said held for hailed
Who's for whose
All other countries are run by little girls.
Kazakhstan is number one exporter of potassium,
Other Central Asian countries have inferior potassium.
Kazakhstan is the greatest country in the world!
All other countries is the home of the gays!
...checks today's date...
Ungrateful colonials.