Yes. I did the same, knowing it was incorrect, but also knowing that you excel at type-ins. Just testing you quizmaster, you passed. Not sure why sillie doesn't want it accepted.
Neil Armstrong was actually supposed to say "That's one small step for a man..." but he missed the "a". NASA then tried to save face and claimed that "static" obscured the "a".
It can be understood, but it doesn't mean anything. If being understood was all they wanted, they could just release it as the slogan for the moon landing campaign, and Neil didn't need to say it at all. The point is, you want the very first words spoken on the moon to be perfect or it's a bad omen, and as it is, the fact that he messed it up was clearly very embarrassing or they wouldn't have covered it up.
So there allready was this tradition that it is considered to be a bad omen if the first words spoken on the moon arent perfect?? how can that be when noone had been there yet..
I think it was just a PR standpoint that made it embarrassing. I remember wondering why everyone was making such a giant deal about a possibly skipped article, but Pen does make a good point. It's kind of like an inaugural address with a typo in it.
The problem is the "a" changes the meaning of the sentence. "A man" is one man, whereas just "man" is every man, or indeed every person, since "man" can be used as equivalent of "mankind". So basically, without the "a", he's saying "one small step for mankind, one giant leap for mankind".
I feel like asking for Artemis instead of Selena is a bit of a miss. She was the goddess of the moon who drove the moon chariot across the night sky. Artemis is the goddess of the hunt, and also a goddess of the moon. The moon association is more of a side dish with her. (Double checked both Wikipedia and Greek Mythology.com to make sure I wasn't talking out of my butt.) And, while Artemis is the only correct answer to this question as it is worded, as far as I can tell, just seems like the not the best choice for moon goddesses.
The first words on the moon was actually "Contact light", uttered by Buzz Aldrin as the instrument light turned on once the eagle had made contact with the lunar surface.
Aldrin: Contact Light. Armstrong (on-board): Shutdown. Aldrin: Okay. Engine Stop. Aldrin: ACA out of Detent. Armstrong: Out of Detent. Auto. Aldrin: Mode Control, both Auto. Descent Engine Command Override, Off. Engine Arm, Off. 413 is in. Armstrong: Engine arm is off. (Pause) Houston, Tranquility Base here. The Eagle has landed. Aldrin: Thank you.
You are correct, the first words on the moon were, "contact light." But technically Aldrin was not on the surface of the moon. The real first-word on the surface is technically "That's" so quizmaster got it wrong. But, when Aldrin said "contact light," he believed the task wasn't completed. So when Armstrong said, "Houston," it was the first word after they thought they had finished landing.
If you really want to get technical, and it seems like you do, no words have been spoken from the surface as nobody has been there barefoot. However, with what you have posted, Armstrong said his words from the ladder before putting his boots on the surface. Aldrin's "Contact" is the first word spoken from the surface inside the LM, and the quiz needs fixing.
Even without being technical, the "contact light" people are just plain wrong. The light didn't illuminate when the lander landed, it illuminated when the three probes touched the surface (they break off, by the way). At that moment, the lander was still flying--still under power, the landing gear on which it rests still above the surface. This explanation includes a diagram showing the difference between "contact" and "on the moon". Touching something below you doesn't mean you're "on" it.
Personally, to be "technical", I wouldn't consider them "on" the surface until the gear is taking the weight of the lander. That happened sometime during this exchange--unambiguously before the call to Houston, and equally unambiguously after engine stop.
Personally I think the question would be more clear if it used the preposition "from". It has connotations that more closely match our intuition about the first words spoken.
It's actually "That's one small step for *a* man, one giant leap for mankind." Niel Armstrong was from Ohio, so his accent, paired with the audio equipment used, made the "a" fade into for, to sound kinda like "...step fra man, one..."
If you consider the contact probes touching the moon (5 feet below the landing pads) to be landing, then the first words on the moon were "contact light". If you don't consider them to have landed until the pads were resting on the surface the first words were "ACA out of detent" (the first item on the post landing checklist). However "the Eagle has landed" were not the first words spoken on the moon.
Michael Collins made the journey to the moon on Apollo 11 and flew the command module alone while Aldrin and Armstrong went to the surface. It was absolutely necessary for someone to pilot the module in orbit or it would've been a one way trip. Collins did all the training, risked his life, contributed to one of the defining moments in human history, and most people have no idea who he is! There's even a comment on this very quiz asking "who was the guy that stayed up in the capsule?" He was just as integral to the mission as the other two but since he didn't actually step foot on the moon he is often left as a footnote or worse completely omitted! When we look back on that fateful day in history, standing tall alongside Neil and Buzz is Michael. When we teach our children to reach for the stars, there is no better inspiration than Michael. When we speak of the indomitable human spirit, Michael's name should be right there. Without Michael there is no moon landing! Put him on the quiz!
The Artemis question is really debatable... The greeks believed in Selene as the moon goddess (and Helius as the sun god). The romans later merged these two brothers with Artemis and Apollo, hence the misconception
I think the missing "a" is not so much of a problem compared to that.
Aldrin: Contact Light. Armstrong (on-board): Shutdown. Aldrin: Okay. Engine Stop. Aldrin: ACA out of Detent. Armstrong: Out of Detent. Auto. Aldrin: Mode Control, both Auto. Descent Engine Command Override, Off. Engine Arm, Off. 413 is in. Armstrong: Engine arm is off. (Pause) Houston, Tranquility Base here. The Eagle has landed. Aldrin: Thank you.
Personally, to be "technical", I wouldn't consider them "on" the surface until the gear is taking the weight of the lander. That happened sometime during this exchange--unambiguously before the call to Houston, and equally unambiguously after engine stop.
Personally I think the question would be more clear if it used the preposition "from". It has connotations that more closely match our intuition about the first words spoken.
Also, the first moon landing was Luna 2. Eagle was used in the first manned moon landing.