The U.S. realized it was fighting invasive wars now, nowhere near its borders in countries that would never think of launching a transoceanic war against the U.S. So in the typical American political scenario of say it and it will be repeated blindly, they called it Defense. As has been noted, the term Homeland Security is synonymous with the word defense, indicating the military is always thousands of miles away in someone else's country.
Looked more into this out of curiosity. It appears the Department of War only involved the army and the air force, with the navy having its own department. Things changed a couple times from 1947-1949, but eventually settled on the current Department of Defense, now including the navy. I would guess the name was changed for clarity as it was a different sort of thing now.
Although I am English I was trying to think of the British political departments then use US terms to fill in the gaps. Obviously not a good stratagy for me as I managed an average score for this one, which shows my ignorance of politics all over the world!
only one of those letters tells what the position is, like it accepts hhs and hud cuz those are the words of the actual position, "usdo" isn't what the quiz is asking
Immigration would be part of Homeland Security. I don't think the names are that odd. They mostly do what they say they do, with the exception of Defense (which does aggressive war) and Homeland Security (which does defense).
Homeland Security does not cover national defense. If, for instance, the United States was invaded by China... then we're much more likely to rely on the Army, Air Force and Navy (Defense) than we are on the TSA, CIA, or ATF (Homeland Security). Homeland Security deals with counter-terrorism.
Kalba, you're exactly right, except that the CIA is an independent agency that reports to the Director of National Intelligence, who reports directly to the President. It's never been part of the Cabinet. And the ATF is under the Department of Justice.
I agree with you on this one, Kalbahamut. Funny you argued basically the opposite position on the Aircraft Carriers quiz, though. Sometimes I think you just like to argue...;)
INS (Immigration and Naturalization Services) was originally established under the Treasury Department, and was then migrated to the departments of Commerce, and then Labor, and finally Justice before ceasing to exist in 2003. In 2003 it was split in three: US Citizenship and Immigration Services, US Customs and Border Protection, and US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), all of which are now under the Department of Homeland Security.
It's the Trump administration's plan to basically dismantle, defund, gut, understaff and destroy all of these possibly excepting State and Defense. If they succeed in their agenda many will be effectively impotent by 2018 after the next mid-term. Then the USA can be a government-free utopia similar to Somalia: Republican paradise.
Also, by your comment I take it that you have no idea what vitally important things most of these departments do, making you an ideal candidate to head one of them up. Send your resume to the White House.
You can usually figure who's at the lower end of the pecking order by who's named Designated Survivor during the State of the Union address. Rick Perry was named the Designator Survivor for the 2019 SOTU. I wasn't sure if that had been made public ahead of time whether it would have made us less or more prone to an attack during the address.
This would be brilliant, especially if he was sat at his seat in the Cabinet, with all the other members sat around him, cheering him on, then watching as he abandons the quiz and begins typing in the comments, furious because he typed in the words ‘terrorist,’ ‘terrorists,’ ‘terrorism’ ‘war on terror,’ ‘Department of Killing Terrorists,’ ‘Department of Bombing Shepherds,’ and only got 1/15 by accident because he started to type ‘Transportation of Terrorists to Guantanamo Bay.’ Someone did try and cheat and shout ‘State!’ at him with 30 secs left but he just typed the word ‘Texas’ and head butted the keyboard until the time ran down.
For HHS it might make more sense since it's name was changed when Education was raised up to require more than just the first word for your answer. And since so few know the full name of HUD, there too you might want to have more spelled out. That said, the cabinet secretaries aren't the only members of the Presidential cabinet.
Adding to the above info from Djilas and kalbahamut: The EPA itself is part of the Dept. of the Interior. There is also an Environment and Natural Resources Division in the Dept. of Justice.
It is within the Department of the Air Force, much like the Marines are within the Department of the Navy. And both are within the Department of Defense.
Uhm, no? While those are synonyms, those aren't what the Cabinet Departments are called. Accepting synonyms for official government departments is not a good idea.
Why not? For me, the interesting aspect of the quiz is (as a non-American) understanding which issues the USA deems worthy of a whole department, and which they don't. For example, I'm not interested in the fact that they have a department with the specific title of "Department of Commerce" - just the fact that they have a department that's functionally identical to what other countries would usually call a Department of Business and/or Trade.
Respectfully, this quiz is about *American* Cabinet Departments. The departments of other nations have zero relevance here, whether they're interesting to you or not. Each department has an official name, which should be the only acceptable title allowed. There isn't a "Department of Farming," the same way there isn't a "Department of Money." While the name sounds similar, in the case of an official government agency/department, you should be required to use only the official titles.
Of all of the leniency requests I've seen on this site, this is probably the most ridiculous. Just because a synonym exists, doesn't mean the department has multiple names. Get good bruv.
Seems to have been a weird influx of 12-year olds making fatuous remarks in this comment section on 6 December and 9 December. Were you assigned this quiz for homework?
State, Defense, Homeland security, Interior, Veteran Affaires, Justice (FBI and ATF)... hm the priorities are somewhat clear and chilling. No wonder US got the highest incarnation rate, if half of their 15 cabinet members deal with security issues. In most normal countries those are covered by 3, max. 4 ministries of out 20.
What do you think the Departments of State, Interior, and VA actually do? Feel free to be chilled if you like, but I'm hard-pressed to think of which "normal" countries don't have some form of, for example, State Department to manage relations with other countries.
Only justice, defense and homeland security deal with security issues. The department of interior manages federal land and resources, and includes the national parks service, the department of state deals with foreign relations, and Veterans affairs gives out retirement and healthcare to veterans.
http://www.jetpunk.com/user-quizzes/36540/cabinet-members-as-of-august-16-2013
See also the end of this list for other related agencies
- Labor - "employment", "work"
- Commerce - "trade", "business"
- Agriculture - "farming"