The list below includes 20 real historical figures and 20 fictional or legendary characters. Click the people who are generally considered to have existed in real life.
I knew it wouldn't be accepted as an answer, but Helen of Troy was 100% a real person. Modern historians are arrogant pricks who think they're smarter than everybody else and go around to every culture on earth telling them that their oral tradition is completely made up.
@iRDM: As a Greek, it is abundantly clear to me and to anyone with basic knowledge on the matter that Homer's epics and other ancient literature on the Trojan War are mythological texts and all individual characters can therefore be presumed to be fictional, even if some conflict could have taken place and served as inspiration. Why would we think otherwise? It's not like we believe in the Twelve Olympians anymore.
Wikipedia says this on Zoroaster: 'Little is known about Zoroaster; most of his life is known only from these scant texts. By any modern standard of historiography, no evidence can place him into a fixed period and the historicization surrounding him may be a part of a trend from before the 10th century AD that historicizes legends and myths.'
With all due respect to both Iranian and Parsee tradition, are we much more confident he was real than we are about Helen of Troy?
Helen of Troy comes from Greek mythology and is a character in the books by Homeros, which never presents itself as a historical book, but as stories. She is as likely to have existed as Achilles, Odyseus, Paris,... which is pretty unlikely. There probably was at one time a girl named Helen that lived in ancient Troy. But we have not reason to believe that there actually was a princess named Helen during a 10 year seige of Troy because of her kidnapping and a fight over her beauty.
Zoroaster is indeed not quite certain, but is at least probably based on somebody (or multiple people). Jesus like described in the bible is also very much up for debate, but even secular wouldn't describe him as completely fictional.
Both are questionable, but I don't think they are in the same ballpark of questionability.
I know a guy called Iñigo Montoya, but OK, I'll accept you mean the other Iñigo Montoya. Even though that guy was born before the film was made (or even the novel was written).
Helen of Troy is a tricky answer, as no one can say for sure whether she really existed or not. Excavations have showed evidence that Troy really existed and at least one major siege had happened, so a Greek princess named Helen would not be a surprise to actually have been real.
Putting Helen of Troy on here is a misstep. Her existence is debated and it's not known for certain whether she was a real person. Just because a story has an element of mythology to it doesn't mean everybody in it didn't exist. Otherwise Jesus himself wouldn't exist.
It really destroys the value of a sudden death quiz to have an ambiguous answer.
I rate this quiz one star just for the poor thinking here.
You could change her for someone more assuredly fictional imho
With all due respect to both Iranian and Parsee tradition, are we much more confident he was real than we are about Helen of Troy?
Zoroaster is indeed not quite certain, but is at least probably based on somebody (or multiple people). Jesus like described in the bible is also very much up for debate, but even secular wouldn't describe him as completely fictional.
Both are questionable, but I don't think they are in the same ballpark of questionability.