thumbnail

Greatest MLB Baseball Players by Franchise

Wins Above Replacement or WAR has come to be the single stat used to determine the performance of any given player. Can you name the 5 players who have accumulated the highest career WAR for every team.
Only counts WAR accumulated with team in question not total career
positions are as listed by baseball references
Quiz by lhr131415
Rate:
Last updated: May 25, 2022
First submittedMay 25, 2022
Times taken28
Average score52.0%
Report this quizReport
20:00
Enter answer here
0
 / 150 guessed
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
WAR
Retired
Player
Position
 
NL
EAST
 
 
Atlanta
 
 
142.5
1976
Hank Aaron
OF/1B
102.7
1906
Kid Nichols
P
99.3
1965
Warren Spahn
P
94.1
1968
Eddie Mathews
3B/1B
88.5
1987
Phil Niekro
P
 
Miami
Marlins
 
35.7
Active
Giancarlo Stanton
OF
26.9
2019
Hanley Ramírez
SS/1B/3B
25.7
2013
Josh Johnson
P
22.4
2010
Luis Castillo
2B
20.8
2011
Dontrelle Willis
P
 
New York
Mets
 
78.8
1986
Tom Seaver
P
49.2
2018
David Wright
3B
46.4
2000
Dwight Gooden
P
42.4
Active
Jacob deGrom
P
36.9
1985
Jerry Koosman
P
 
Philidelpia
Phillies
 
106.8
1989
Mike Schmidt
3B/1B
71.9
1966
Robin Roberts
P
69.4
1988
Steve Carlton
P
62.0
2018
Chase Utley
2B
61.2
1930
Pete Alexander
P
 
Washington
Nationals
 
55.8
1992
Gary Carter
C/OF
49.1
2002
Tim Raines
OF
48.3
1996
Andre Dawson
OF
44.7
1985
Steve Rogers
P
40.2
Active
Max Scherzer
P
 
AL
EAST
 
 
Baltimore
Orioles
 
95.9
2001
Cal Ripken Jr.
SS/3B
78.5
1977
Brooks Robinson
3B
68.5
1984
Jim Palmer
P
56.6
1997
Eddie Murray
1B
54.7
1930
George Sisler
1B
 
Boston
Red Sox
 
122.0
1960
Ted Williams
OF
96.5
1983
Carl Yastrzemski
OF/1B
80.8
2007
Roger Clemens
P
71.9
1999
Wade Boggs
3B
66.7
1911
Cy Young
P
 
New York
Yankees
 
143.2
1935
Babe Ruth
OF/P
113.6
1939
Lou Gehrig
1B
110.2
1968
Mickey Mantle
OF/1B
79.2
1951
Joe DiMaggio
OF
71.3
2014
Derek Jeter
SS
 
Tampa Bay
Rays
 
51.2
Active
Evan Longoria
3B
35.6
2016
Carl Crawford
OF
35.3
2019
Ben Zobrist
2B/OF/SS
31,5
Active
Kevin Kiermaier
OF
21.2
Active
David Price
P
 
Toronto
Blue Jays
 
56.8
1998
Dave Stieb
P
48.0
2013
Roy Halladay
P
38.3
2018
José Bautista
OF/3B
37.5
2001
Tony Fernández
SS/3B/2B
36.8
2009
Carlos Delgado
1B
WAR
Retired
Player
Position
 
NL
CENTRAL
 
 
Chicago
Cubs
 
84.7
1897
Cap Anson
1B/3B/C
72.1
1974
Ron Santo
3B
68.1
1997
Ryne Sandberg
2B/3B
67.7
1971
Ernie Banks
1B/SS
61.7
1976
Billy Williams
OF/1B
 
Cincinatti
Reds
 
78.1
1986
Pete Rose
OF/1B/3B
75.1
1983
Johnny Bench
C/3B/1B
70.5
2004
Barry Larkin
SS
63.7
1976
Frank Robinson
OF/1B
63.7
Active
Joey Votto
1B
 
Milwaukee
Brewers
 
77.4
1993
Robin Yount
SS/OF
59.9
1998
Paul Molitor
DH/3B/2B
47.1
2020
Ryan Braun
OF/3B
30.7
1987
Cecil Cooper
1B
30.3
1994
Teddy Higuera
P
 
Pittsburgh
Pirates
 
120.1
1917
Honus Wagner
SS/OF/1B
94.8
1972
Roberto Clemente
OF
70.1
1945
Paul Waner
OF
67.6
1948
Arky Vaughan
SS/3B
57.5
1982
Willie Stargell
OF/1B
 
St. Louis
Cardinals
 
128.6
1963
Stan Musial
OF/1B
91.8
1937
Rogers Hornsby
2B/SS/3B
89.2
1975
Bob Gibson
P
86.5
Active
Albert Pujols
1B/OF/3B
65.9
1996
Ozzie Smith
SS
 
AL
CENTRAL
 
 
Chicago
White Sox
 
77.6
1950
Luke Appling
SS/3B
70.6
1946
Ted Lyons
P
68.3
2008
Frank Thomas
DH/1B
67.0
1930
Eddie Collins
2B
65.9
1917
Ed Walsh
P
 
Cleveland
Guardians
 
79.6
1916
Nap Lajoie
2B/1B
74.8
1928
Tris Speaker
OF
63.5
1956
Bob Feller
P
62.0
1952
Lou Boudreau
SS
53.2
1928
Stan Coveleski
P
 
Detroit
Tigers
 
145.0
1928
Ty Cobb
OF
92.9
1974
Al Kaline
OF/1B
84.8
1942
Charlie Gehringer
2B
75.1
1995
Lou Whitaker
2B
70.7
1996
Alan Trammell
SS
 
Kansas City
Royals
 
88.6
1993
George Brett
3B/1B
47.0
2004
Kevin Appier
P
44.8
1984
Amos Otis
OF
42.5
1994
Willie Wilson
OF
40.7
2001
Bret Saberhagen
P
 
Minnesota
Twins
 
164.9
1927
Walter Johnson
P
63.8
1985
Rod Carew
1B/2B
60.4
1975
Harmon Killebrew
1B/3B/OF
55.2
2018
Joe Mauer
C/1B
53.9
1934
Sam Rice
OF
WAR
Retired
Player
Position
 
NL
WEST
 
 
Arizona
Diamondbacks
 
50.9
2009
Randy Johnson
P
39.9
Active
Paul Goldschmidt
1B
31.1
2009
Brandon Webb
P
30.0
2008
Luis Gonzalez
OF
25.3
2007
Curt Schilling
P
 
Colorado
Rockies
 
61.8
2013
Todd Helton
1B
48.3
2005
Larry Walker
OF/1B
40.1
Active
Nolan Arenado
3B
39.5
2019
Troy Tulowitzki
SS
26.8
Active
Trevor Story
SS/2B
 
Los Angeles
Dodgers
 
73.3
Active
Clayton Kershaw
P
68.4
1958
Pee Wee Reese
SS/3B
67.1
1969
Don Drysdale
P
65.3
1964
Duke Snider
OF
61.7
1956
Jackie Robinson
2B/3B/1B
 
San Diego
Padres
 
69.2
2001
Tony Gwynn
OF
32.0
1995
Dave Winfield
OF
26.8
2016
Jake Peavy
P
25.8
2010
Trevor Hoffman
P
22.6
2004
Andy Ashby
P
 
San Francisco
Giants
 
154.5
1973
Willie Mays
OF
112.5
2007
Barry Bonds
OF
110.8
1947
Mel Ott
OF/3B
106.7
1916
Christy Mathewson
P
68.5
1943
Carl Hubbell
P
 
AL
WEST
 
 
Houston
Astros
 
79.9
2005
Jeff Bagwell
1B
65.5
2007
Craig Biggio
2B/C/OF
51.4
1988
José Cruz
OF
49.6
1986
César Cedeño
OF/1B
48.1
2013
Lance Berkman
OF/1B
 
Los Angeles
Angles
 
78.7
Active
Mike Trout
OF
51.8
2002
Chuck Finley
P
45.9
1978
Jim Fregosi
SS/1B/3B
40.5
2006
Tim Salmon
OF
40.2
1993
Nolan Ryan
P
 
Oakland
A's
 
77.2
1917
Eddie Plank
P
72.7
2003
Rickey Henderson
OF
64.8
1941
Lefty Grove
P
61.2
1945
Jimmie Foxx
1B/3B/C
57.4
1930
Eddie Collins
2B
 
Seattle
Mariners
 
70.6
2010
Ken Griffey Jr.
OF
68.4
2004
Edgar Martinez
DH/3B
56.4
2019
Ichiro Suzuki
OF
49.7
2019
Félix Hernández
P
39.0
2009
Randy Johnson
P
 
Texas
Rangers
 
50.0
2011
Iván Rodríguez
C
44.6
2005
Rafael Palmeiro
1B/OF
41.1
2018
Adrián Beltré
3B
36.3
1989
Buddy Bell
3B/OF
35.0
2019
Ian Kinsler
2B
No comments yet