For this quiz, all points shall be distributed equally among all quiz takers. Or is that socialism? Or Stalinism? Or Leninism? Or Maoism? Or aren't they all the same anyway so that we can simply equivocate?
Good idea @mwierenga. I'm also putting any enemies of this quiz in a points gulag where they will be completely stripped of points until such time as they have been rehabilitated.
Yeah Nepal was added by QM only when he enabled it for points. Since the time frame Wikipedia had been edited. (Although surely I didn't make the quiz in 09!)
North Korea was communist, but the Marxist/Leninist ideology was replaced in their constitution in the early 1970s. Today they follow Juche, which is a policy system that places extreme emphasis on military strength and the cult of personality that surrounds the Supreme Leader and the whole Kim family.
That rather proves the opposite. Did Ceausescu look the same as a Romanian peasant? Inequality in practice is a near-universal feature of Marxist-Leninist systems, although some leaders do a better job of not flaunting it than others.
thats actually incorrect, the military aprt isnt the "juche", its the "songun", and the cult of personality is a cultural thing, not part of the official state ideology
Every communist country, especially the single-party states, wants to seem democratic. That's why they create more parties, but those always work together with the communist party. So there is no political opposition to them anyway.
According to the article, other parties must "must accept the leading role of the CPC as a condition of being allowed to exist". So I would say that de-facto it is a one-party state.
Then you also have Belarus, the last dictatorship in Europe and also Turkmenistan who have those Turkmenbashi leaders who build golden statues of themselves. #selfesteemgoals
These countries are legally communist, which means the constitution says that it is. None of these countries are actually communist. hell, by definition a country with a government couldn't be communist because communism is a form of anarchy.
Communism, by definition, is a form of anarchy, so no government would even exist in a communist society. Just because they claim to be socialist (isn't the same as communism anyway) doesn't make them socialist. The countries on this list are legally communist, as in the constitution says so, which Venezuela also doesn't have. the only reason Nepal is one here is because the communist party currently controls the government.
Are you sure about all that? Because in practice, it seems to be more of a form of totalitarianism, which is obviously the exact opposite of anarchism. On every political compass I've seen, it's very AuthRight. If you can, I would like you to provide a source for that "communism is a form of anarchism" nonsense.
None of these countries are technically communist, nor were any countries ever. North Korea for example has some fascist ideals, and there is no way everyone is equal in that country, (very very few people have wealth, while everyone else is left poor). Therefore I think it is correct to exclude North Korea.
By the purest principles of Marxism, 'communist state' is an oxymoron. Once communism has been attained the state withers away. I guess we'll just have to rub along as we are until then.
Well inequality between the rulers and the ordinary people is a fundamental of communism in practice... it's a fundamental of lots of other repressive systems as well, of course.
No truely Capitalist state has ever existed either - in reality all economies are mixtures between free market forces and state intervention. So I don't think it is fair to say communism can't work/ hsan't worked or is incompatible with human nature. Marx and other left wing thinkers have had a huge influence on economics and politics as have Adam Smith and other free market advocates
Capitalism and a free market economy are not exactly the same things. Capitalism and regulation are not mutually exclusive. But you could say that pretty much all countries today are a mixture of capitalist and socialist. I don't really know much about North Korea's economy but they might be the only country in the world with close to a 100% planned economy?
You should learn more about communism... Just because a country has social programs like bolsa família doesn't mean it's communist like the countries listed above...
Just because you have a (so called) progressive party doesn't make it communist. Also, by definition, communism is a form of anarchy, so there wouldn't even be a government or any parties for that matter!
none of these countries are actually communist anyway. Communism, by definition, is a form of anarchy, so no government would even exist in a communist society. (also Nepal is decent at protecting human rights, but nowhere near perfect).
May I ask, why was Nepal included? There are other countries that have a communist party and are a "multi-party state". So what makes Nepal so special.
Before 1996 Nepal was a monarchy where the king and queen held all of the power. However, the average Nepali saw no improvement in quality of life and average citizen was poor. From 1996-2006 Maoist rebels started a civil war in hopes of helping their communities. Eventually in 2006 the monarchy stepped down and the Communist party was democratically elected and has won the popular vote to this day, even though there are otherpolitical parties in Nepal.
none of these countries are actually "communist", they are just legally, as in the constitution says so, communist. Angola doesn't have that in their constitution.
I always find it interesting that these quizzes completely ignore the marxist countries of Africa. Almost all of them fell to the reds after the Europeans left. A couple of them were made into nice places by Europeans before completely crumbling under Marxist rule (Rhodesia, South Africa, Angola, Mozambique)
These countries are legally, as in the constitution says, communist. They are not actually listing communist countries, or else this quiz would have 0 countries in it!
Well... the one-party state is far more a communist than a fascist practice. The USSR existed before any of the fascist regimes came into being, and there have been many more communist one-party states than fascist ones. And I'm not sure how democratic the original republic, the Roman one, was. Not much though, I don't think.
Literally every Marxist-Leninist country is/was called a republic. Even the big daddy itself, Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. China being that too doesn't feel that noteworthy to me.
single party state does not imply fascism. In fact a single party state can still be democratic if people get to vote on their representatives directly.
As a devout communist, I am appauled to see that people think there are multi-party communist regimes. Communism only works with one party in charge. ONLY ONE SUPREME LEADER CAN RULE!!!!!!!!!
Maybe you should look at the track record of communist Grenada and Burkina Faso who after the revolution experienced economic wonders and massive human rights improvements. These governments were then overthrown. Do you think that's a failure? I don't think so.
These countries are legally, as in the constitution says, communist. This is not actually listing communist countries, or else this quiz would have 0 countries in it! Also, a "communist state" is inherently oxymoronic, because by definition, communism is a form of anarchy.
These countries are legally, as in the constitution says, communist. Just because you have a (so called) progressive party doesn't make it communist. The only reason Nepal is on here is because the communist party of Nepal currently has a majority in the government. Also, by definition, communism is a form of anarchy, so there wouldn't even be a state!
This is a list of countries that have communism in their constitution and a communist party in power. North Korea rightfully is not on here and Nepal is rightfully here.
By definition, communism is a form of anarchy, so there wouldn't even be a state! So technically, none of these countries are actually communist. And btw, that makes the USSR and the Warsaw pact also not communist, as well as many, many others.
Wow! Nepal... and l thinking of a multitude of Central Asian (especially Kazakhstan), South-East Asian (Vietnam, Laos?), Southern/Central African and even other Latin American states (besides Cuba), but Nepal? Never, especially since it borders Tibet...
READ THE HECKING OTHER COMMENTS
China is officially a Republic, which implies democracy.
But it's a single-party state, which implies fascism.
But it's a communist party.
China is the rainbow of ideologies.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/People%27s_Progressive_Party_(Guyana)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nepali_Congress