Fun fact: If we get overly technical to the point of tedium, then the “W” in Moscow acts as a vowel. Of course no one other than linguistics students consider the W a vowel when it’s in a diphthong.
Google AI Overview is telling me: 'In the word "Tokyo", the "y" is considered a consonant. Explanation: While "y" can sometimes act as a vowel in English, in Japanese, it is always considered a consonant and is often used in combination with other consonants to create a unique sound, like in "kyo".'
Not that I trust AI. Can someone cite a reliable source that says the Y is a vowel?
Easy evidence: in English, it’s three syllables and pronounced the same as countries who spell it Tokio. Sometimes English just uses a Y when it probably should just use an I. Look it up on Merriam Webster and it lists it as tō-kē-ō. The y makes an ē sound, meaning it’s a vowel in this case.
Disagree. I think Merriam Webster is wrong on this one. Wikipedia agrees with me. It is two syllables and 'y' is a consonant in this case.
If you accept that there are correct and incorrect ways of pronouncing place names, and that the correct way is determined by the tradition of the people who live in that place, the case for three syllables in Tokyo is only supported by a mispronunciation. Listen to the audio clip on Wikipedia for the correct sound.
I disagree with both Quizmaster and Dimby. There may be a case for calling it 'two and a half syllables', but I don't hear it pronounced 'To-kee-o'. Do you say 'Pee-on-yang'?
Here's a fun fact...Alaskans voted in the 70s to move the capital from Juneau to Willow. Then 4 years later, the government of Alaska said they couldn't afford it and just told them tough...it stays Juneau. You never know...this may be a similar situation.
Having apologised earlier, I now retract this, as I think I was right in my original post about Tarawa.
I don’t know how to post Wikipedia links here, but try typing in “Tarawa” to see what it says. Conversely, you can open the page for “Kiribati” and let me know what it says under “Capital”.
I know it’s not gospel, but I thought it served as a Jetpunk arbiter?
Where is Colombo in all of this? I know that this quiz's creator believes that Y is excluded as it could be a vowel so I won't say anything about Tokyo or Kyiv but where is Colombo?
Last time I checked, JetPunk has either one as the capital, unless SJK is more recognized here.
Not that I trust AI. Can someone cite a reliable source that says the Y is a vowel?
If you accept that there are correct and incorrect ways of pronouncing place names, and that the correct way is determined by the tradition of the people who live in that place, the case for three syllables in Tokyo is only supported by a mispronunciation. Listen to the audio clip on Wikipedia for the correct sound.
I don’t know how to post Wikipedia links here, but try typing in “Tarawa” to see what it says. Conversely, you can open the page for “Kiribati” and let me know what it says under “Capital”.
I know it’s not gospel, but I thought it served as a Jetpunk arbiter?
Not sure if there's a rule I'm missing?
Last time I checked, JetPunk has either one as the capital, unless SJK is more recognized here.