| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The one in the wheelchair | Artie | 98%
|
| The gay warbler | Blaine | 98%
|
| The dead one (R.I.P) | Finn | 93%
|
| The other gay one | Kurt | 93%
|
| The pregnant one | Quinn | 93%
|
| The stripper lesbian | Santana | 92%
|
| The cheerleading coach | Sue | 92%
|
| The teacher | Will | 92%
|
| The boy Asian | Mike | 91%
|
| The girl Asian | Tina | 91%
|
| The mohawk (before shaven) | Puck | 90%
|
| The dumb bisexual | Brittany | 88%
|
| The OCD ginger | Emma | 88%
|
| The homeless blonde (temporary) | Sam | 82%
|
| The principal/caretaker | Figgins | 79%
|
| The fat one | Mercedes | 78%
|
| The irish kid | Rory | 78%
|
| The gay bully | Dave | 75%
|
| The mean cheerleader | Kitty | 72%
|
| The trans-gender coach | Beiste | 67%
|
| The bulimic one | Marley | 65%
|
| The lady boy | Wade | 63%
|
| The alchoholic | April | 48%
|
| The "I thought you'd never ask" woman | Holly | 42%
|
| The one with the big nose | Rachel | 17%
|