| Goals scored | Player | Years | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 179 | John Wark | 1975–84, 1988–90, 1991–96 | 95%
|
| 55 | Conor Chaplin | 2021– | 90%
|
| 135 | Paul Mariner | 1976–84 | 89%
|
| 227 | Ray Crawford | 1958–63, 1966–69 | 86%
|
| 80 | Alan Brazil | 1978–83 | 83%
|
| 62 | David Johnson | 1997–2000 | 82%
|
| 55 | Darren Bent | 2001–05 | 77%
|
| 67 | Daryl Murphy | 2010, 2011–12, 2012–13, 2013–16 | 77%
|
| 96 | Eric Gates | 1973–85 | 71%
|
| 179 | Ted Phillips | 1954–64 | 70%
|
| 104 | Trevor Whymark | 1970–79 | 67%
|
| 61 | Pablo Couñago | 2001–05, 2007–10 | 63%
|
| 55 | James Scowcroft | 1995–2001, 2005 | 58%
|
| 73 | Jason Dozzell | 1984–93, 1997 | 57%
|
| 64 | Chris Kiwomya | 1988–95 | 54%
|
| 56 | Simon Milton | 1987–98 | 33%
|
| 54 | Colin Viljoen | 1967–78 | 32%
|
| 56 | Bryan Hamilton | 1971–75 | 24%
|
| 143 | Tom Garneys | 1951–58 | 19%
|
| 52 | John Elsworthy | 1949–64 | 16%
|
| 69 | Frank Brogan | 1964–70 | 11%
|
| 92 | Tommy Parker | 1945–56 | 11%
|
| 66 | Gerry Baker | 1963–67 | 10%
|